Jump to content

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

SauceBoss

PFF posts its ratings for all teams

Recommended Posts

xtheronx    224

beason didn't perform well last year although that was almost certainly due to injury

so .. you're saying their grading is based solely on last season? If so .. Beason only played in 4 games .. either way they're way off on that one .. he's not on the same level as those other guys ..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JawnyBlaze    5,246

Tannehill is as good as Cam, both being "above average" O.o  Dwan Edwards and Godfrey are equally bad as Nakamura at below average O.o

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




frash.exe    10,817

so .. you're saying their grading is based solely on last season? If so .. Beason only played in 4 games .. either way they're way off on that one .. he's not on the same level as those other guys ..

 

not exactly sure but here is our part from that series of snapshots

 

https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2013/07/03/neils-nfl-daily-july-3-2013/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Chaos    8,174

This is funny.  They use our nickle defensive package to put three CB's on the field, taking off Davis.  Davis should rank above average and remove Capt as below average.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MasterAwesome    330

Their criteria for "elite" seems pretty harsh...Haloti Ngata didn't get an elite grade by them and he's generally considered the best at his position.

And what's up with London Fletcher getting a "poor"? Didn't he make the Pro Bowl over Kuechly as an alternate?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JawnyBlaze    5,246

Fletcher is overrated and is getting misdirected recognition these days based on the longetivity and consistency of his career, but I certainly wouldn't call him poor.  I'd probably put him at average.

 

And there are some "elite" grades that I'm scratching my head at if players like Graham and Kuechly aren't getting "elite".  Like Reggie Wayne.  Yea, he's real good, but I wouldn't call him elite these days.  I woulda made him the dark green category.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nagai    74

PFF's ratings are based on stats. How can you expect them to give a high grade to someone who's been injured last year? They're not gonna invent some training camp, recovering-from-injury metric just for something like this. I trust these guys -- their evaluations are certainly more justified than the regular fan's.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JawnyBlaze    5,246

PFF's ratings are based on stats. How can you expect them to give a high grade to someone who's been injured last year? They're not gonna invent some training camp, recovering-from-injury metric just for something like this. I trust these guys -- their evaluations are certainly more justified than the regular fan's.

 

If it was just based on stats they wouldn't have graded Cam and Tannehill the same.

 

I do like PFF and usually value their stat systems.  This time, however, I think there is less value in what they're saying.  And I'm not even just complaining about what they said about some Panthers.  Like someone pointed out above, if Jimmy Graham isn't an elite TE who the hell is?!  A fully healthy Gronk is the only TE that's better than Graham today.  Which means Graham is the best and will probably be the best for a while to come.  And rating Dwan Edwards the same as Nakamura is a joke.  Dwan was bad in run defense, but good in pass defense.  In every aspect of the game, Nakamura was worse than Dwan's worst aspect. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×