Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

What positions are the Saints supposedly lacking in 3-4?

99 posts in this topic

Posted · Report post

The Saints lost their best defensive player to the IR. (Will Smith )

yet they go 10 an 6 with a converting 3 -4 defense without 3-4 personnel.
Hmmmm

I keep reading the same comments on rivals board, but yet nobody can elaborate.

First off, lets get the Will Smith was best player thing out the way. Last year he was worst graded guy on entire team and ranked 108 out of 109 of all 4-3 DE's. the only thing he brought was veteran leadership since he's been with team for a while, but he was last year WORST player on defense. To put it in perspective, Gallette had more sacks and about the same QB pressures in just 460 snaps compared to Smiths 1089 snaps.


Now for the "they don't have 3-4 personnel" statement.

As for personnel, lets break it down. The DBs are not affected by 3-4 or 4-3 and with addition of Vacarro, Greer healthy, P Rob looking decent in preseason, Corey White continuing the improvement streak started last 3 games of last year, and finally Ryan understanding Harper is best used near the line in run support and blitz and not in coverage, the DB group will be fine.

Now for the 3-4 personnel, the front 3 not only have looked solid, we have guys with future breakout status not only playing but in that depth. Cam and Hicks have been great with Bunkley solid in middle with some young raw talent behind them. I don't think with the guys at front 3 anyone would say we don't have good guys up there or lack personnel.

Finally the one glaring weakness is obviously the 4 LBs. Lofton is experienced and pretty solid 3 down LB on inside, but the other guys are question marks with no full time playing and both OLB spending preseason hurt. In limited play Tez and Gallette have both put up great numbers and Gallette has played about half of the snaps last year, but Tez only played a little over 100 snaps of a 1100 snap season, so they are unproven as full year players.

Then Vilmas spot is biggest question mark, is he healthy enough to play after another knee surgery? The good news is Hawthorne is a vet that played great in preseason and can play either inside or outside.

So bottom line, I believe we have the guys for 3-4, yet the LB core is the only question due to lack of playtime and not much depth. On the other hand most defensive plays are in sub packages, so base 3-4 isn't a big alignment anyway, and the play so farchas been really good at most positions,


So name the exact position the Saints don't have to play 3-4?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

worst defense in NFL history fatty

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Just to attach some info, here is the total preseason grades of all 3-4 DEs. I guess a team without 3-4 personnel shouldn't have any guys graded in top 4, much less 3 of the top 4!

1185047_207781599383992_669256141_n.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

worst defense in NFL history fatty


That's the same ignorant type statements I'm talking about. What does the 2012 defenses, with a different Def coordinator, a different defensive scheme, a completely different philosophy, lacking a head coach for accountability and bringing back at most 5 of 11 guys as starters have to do with Ryans 3-4 pressure defense? Or are you unable to have a factually based football conversation?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

i think you're too stupid to realize that you just answered your own question

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

i think you're too stupid to realize that you just answered your own question


Actually I gave my personal opinion that our OLBs are not completely proven due to lack of full time play as a starter, although Gallette did actually play his way to start last year and ended up playing half the snaps, so there is not much question with him. Martez Wilson only has a little over a hundred snaps, mostly because he was used as a situational pass rusher, but was great in limited play.

On the other hand, I'm just pointing out we have two outside guys moving from part time to full time starters as well as a question about Vilma's health with a solid vet ready to play in his spot if he can't go. Yet that is NOT the same thing as saying we don't have the personnel.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

So Pat, where does the Saints defense rank at the end of the year?

 

Top ten?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

the 4 LBs, the most important part of a 3-4, other than NT is questionable.  25% of your 3-4 defense, one of the most important components.   other than vaccaro you guys have nobody.

 

if you don't have the LBs for a 3-4, or a badass NT, then you do not have the components to run a 3-4.   you answered your own question dumbass.

 

ps.  if you want to have a serious conversation about this, try posting it in NFL Central you fucktard

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

oh, the secondary will be affected when they have to keep up with receivers longer because your front seven generates the pressure of a mild cold front.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

That's the same ignorant type statements I'm talking about. What does the 2012 defenses, with a different Def coordinator, a different defensive scheme, a completely different philosophy, lacking a head coach for accountability and bringing back at most 5 of 11 guys as starters have to do with Ryans 3-4 pressure defense? Or are you unable to have a factually based football conversation?

 

1.  Rob Ryan sucks

2.  You need pass rushing OLBs that can also play coverage.

3.  No pass rush means your DBs are going to get shredded..

4.  COMPLETELY NEW PHILOSOPHY, players must learn, AND they are already pathetic.

 

 

But allow me to translate that into something you might, possibly, understand:

 

You're shitty defense with your new shitty DC is going to sh!t out a shittier defense than your already world record setting shittiest defense of all time 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Worst defense in history

Sent from my SCH-I545 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

1. Rob Ryan sucks
2. You need pass rushing OLBs that can also play coverage.
3. No pass rush means your DBs are going to get shredded..
4. COMPLETELY NEW PHILOSOPHY, players must learn, AND they are already pathetic.


But allow me to translate that into something you might, possibly, understand:

You're shitty defense with your new shitty DC is going to sh!t out a shittier defense than your already world record setting shittiest defense of all time


New defensive philosophy that is very similiar to what they had been doing with GW for 3 years has been picked up pretty well so far according to players when interviewed and also according to coaches interviews. So unless both player and coaches are flat out lying AND you have some direct info to Saints locker room and meetings, you're wrong.


The same "shitty defense" is bringing back just 5 guys and 4 of those were on 2009 superbowl winning defense that faced 3 HOF QBs along the way


This preseason the Saints defense created 18 sacks and 71 QB pressure without a ton of blitzes, Panther only had 15 sacks and 54 QB pressures. So if those numbers mean Saints had zero pass rush, then I ask you why is Panthers pass rush so sad and nonexistent?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

New defensive philosophy that is very similiar to what they had been doing with GW for 3 years has been picked up pretty well so far according to players when interviewed and also according to coaches interviews. So unless both player and coaches are flat out lying AND you have some direct info to Saints locker room and meetings, you're wrong.


The same "shitty defense" is bringing back just 5 guys and 4 of those were on 2009 superbowl winning defense that faced 3 HOF QBs along the way


This preseason the Saints defense created 18 sacks and 71 QB pressure without a ton of blitzes, Panther only had 15 sacks and 54 QB pressures. So if those numbers mean Saints had zero pass rush, then I ask you why is Panthers pass rush so sad and nonexistent?

 

you'll find out how wrong you are when the seasons starts...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

New defensive philosophy that is very similiar to what they had been doing with GW for 3 years has been picked up pretty well so far according to players when interviewed and also according to coaches interviews. So unless both player and coaches are flat out lying AND you have some direct info to Saints locker room and meetings, you're wrong.


The same "shitty defense" is bringing back just 5 guys and 4 of those were on 2009 superbowl winning defense that faced 3 HOF QBs along the way


This preseason the Saints defense created 18 sacks and 71 QB pressure without a ton of blitzes, Panther only had 15 sacks and 54 QB pressures. So if those numbers mean Saints had zero pass rush, then I ask you why is Panthers pass rush so sad and nonexistent?

 

I guess you'll be fine, then.  What are you worried about?  You'll score >50ppg and hold teams to <10ppg.  Best team in the history of everness.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

did you mean to post this on the saints board?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

the saints really need a NT for the 3-4, a big fatass to plug up the middle and basically just be someone you can't move or get rid of

 

in other words, they should sign you

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

the saints really need a NT for the 3-4, a big fatass to plug up the middle and basically just be someone you can't move or get rid of

in other words, they should sign you

or rob ryan?

Sent from my ADR910L using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I keep reading the same comments on rivals board, but yet nobody can elaborate.

First off, lets get the Will Smith was best player thing out the way. Last year he was worst graded guy on entire team and ranked 108 out of 109 of all 4-3 DE's. the only thing he brought was veteran leadership since he's been with team for a while, but he was last year WORST player on defense. To put it in perspective, Gallette had more sacks and about the same QB pressures in just 460 snaps compared to Smiths 1089 snaps.


Now for the "they don't have 3-4 personnel" statement.

As for personnel, lets break it down. The DBs are not affected by 3-4 or 4-3 and with addition of Vacarro, Greer healthy, P Rob looking decent in preseason, Corey White continuing the improvement streak started last 3 games of last year, and finally Ryan understanding Harper is best used near the line in run support and blitz and not in coverage, the DB group will be fine.

Now for the 3-4 personnel, the front 3 not only have looked solid, we have guys with future breakout status not only playing but in that depth. Cam and Hicks have been great with Bunkley solid in middle with some young raw talent behind them. I don't think with the guys at front 3 anyone would say we don't have good guys up there or lack personnel.

Finally the one glaring weakness is obviously the 4 LBs. Lofton is experienced and pretty solid 3 down LB on inside, but the other guys are question marks with no full time playing and both OLB spending preseason hurt. In limited play Tez and Gallette have both put up great numbers and Gallette has played about half of the snaps last year, but Tez only played a little over 100 snaps of a 1100 snap season, so they are unproven as full year players.

Then Vilmas spot is biggest question mark, is he healthy enough to play after another knee surgery? The good news is Hawthorne is a vet that played great in preseason and can play either inside or outside.

So bottom line, I believe we have the guys for 3-4, yet the LB core is the only question due to lack of playtime and not much depth. On the other hand most defensive plays are in sub packages, so base 3-4 isn't a big alignment anyway, and the play so farchas been really good at most positions,


So name the exact position the Saints don't have to play 3-4?

so the bench from the worst defense in nfl history is being promoted to the starting ranks & you're happy about that? that makes 2 of us. You sure your a saints fan?

Sent from my ADR910L using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

did you mean to post this on the saints board?


Funny, no matter where I post, when I post, or the subject, there is always one certainty, my resident stalker is there reading and commenting every time. It's cool, I'm used to having the jealous poors hanging on my every word, one of the perks/curses of growing up very wealthy. Don't worry Phil, I'll acknowledge you if I need a drink poured.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Funny, no matter where I post, when I post, or the subject, there is always one certainty, my resident stalker is there reading and commenting every time. It's cool, I'm used to having the jealous poors hanging on my every word, one of the perks/curses of growing up very wealthy. Don't worry Phil, I'll acknowledge you if I need a drink poured.

 

uhh ive been perusing these boards for far longer than your miserable residency here so responding to the tripe you vomit all over the internet isn't outside my daily range of browsing. you're the one farting around on another team's message board to the tune of a thousand posts in about a year erstwhile demanding respect for your awesometacular life

 

[spoiler] eat less [/spoiler]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

the saints really need a NT for the 3-4, a big fatass to plug up the middle and basically just be someone you can't move or get rid of

in other words, they should sign you


Bunkley has been solid at NT and John Jenkins was a beast of raw talent this preseason and looks like he might take Bunkleys job before end of year!



Here is last years grades, I only showed top 1/3 so you won't find FUA on the list, he was 83rd out of 85 graded! Keep on mind this is NT and DT together, so if it was just a list of NT, his rank would be even higher.

But hey great point, forget the guy that graded in top third of all DT and NTs and the raw talent that played great all preseason, take our cast off that was basically worst ranked of all DTs and that will make your line better! LMFAO! Moron! What's next genius, cut Brees and pick up Clausen!? Lol

1185058_207863569375795_1528793205_n.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

saints defense will be complete and utter shit

 

fact

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Big A, ranked the OL yall played and rank the OL we played.

 

Also your DEF looked horrible in the open field vs a quality OL. The positive your 1st team DEF allowed only one TD and 3 FG's, in the 1st half. (that still equates to 32 points in a full game), I know I know its preseason. 

 

I do think that your DEF will be better,  but I would say finishing 3rd best in the DIV is yall ceiling, injuries, new system and who is on yall schedule will cause Rob Ryan to lose his hair.

 

But I still see you guys making some noise, Brees is that good.  He only needs the DEF to improve slightly to win a few more games compared to last year, BUT......... Our DIV plays tougher teams then we did last year.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites