Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

TruCatzFan

Carolina Panthers Double Coverage: Seahawks at Panthers (article)

7 posts in this topic

In this article ESPN writers David Newton and Terry Blount (for the Panthers and Seahawks respectively) go toe to toe on a joint piece they did together... Here's a taste

Let's get right to the question most people are asking: Who is the better quarterback? Carolina's Cam Newton or Seattle's Russell Wilson?

Newton: I know Wilson and the Seahawks are the sweethearts of the league after making the playoffs last season. But if I were starting a team, I'd take Newton, and not because we share the same last name. I know the Panthers would. They talked last season about drafting Wilson to back up the first pick of the 2011 draft before Seattle got him in the third round. Backup! Look, Wilson is a solid player who is surrounded by a better supporting cast than Newton has had in his first two seasons and has again this year. Wilson does some great things with his arm and legs. He makes good decisions. Newton would kill for his completion percentage of 64.1 last season. But Newton is one of those special players who, at 6-foot-5 and 245 pounds, can do things the 5-11, 206-pound Wilson can only dream of. Go back and look at the 72-yard touchdown run Newton capped with a flip into the end zone in a 30-20 victory against a one-loss Atlanta team last season and you'll see what I'm talking about. Wilson's biggest edge comes in leadership, and I believe you'll see Newton step it up in that department this year. I see his stock on the rise. Of all the first-year quarterbacks who made the playoffs last year, Wilson is my choice to have a sophomore slump.

Blount: Newt, I honestly tell you that the Seahawks coaches and players would take Wilson every day of the week, and frankly, I think so would most NFL coaches. In the more than 30 years I've covered sports, I've never met a more impressive young man than Wilson. He's just one of those once-in-a-generation-type athletes who you look at him and listen to him, then you say, "This guy is going places in life." Yes, Cam has more experience, and, obviously, more size. He's an exceptional athlete, a man that Seattle coach Pete Carroll called "a phenomenal talent." But he isn't the team leader that Wilson is, and won't make as many good decisions at key moments as Wilson will.

http://espn.go.com/blog/seattle-seahawks/post/_/id/198/double-coverage-seahawks-at-panthers

The article goes on, and Newton basically says we might have a winning record but no playoffs but maybe... I don't know... I though I liked Newton, but he had a chance to bury the other writer and didn't take it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i don't think it was about 'burying' the other writer. both stated their opinions. it wasn't literally toe to toe

 

both raise valid points

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cam is better though

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like the Double Coverage concept.

 

Newt isn't as high on the team as we are, but what else is new.

 

I did think it was funny that Blount called Wilson a once in a generation type talent- which I disagree with. He's good, but until he shows that he can put the offense on his back and carry them he's just a smart, accurate mobile QB.

 

Cam carried the offense the entire 2011 season and for much of last year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Being a State fan I can tell you that Wilson is indeed a unique talent. He left state without winning. He couldn't win at Wisconsin and I'll wait and see if he wins in Seattle.

 

He has all the pieces around him...but he cannot take over a game. He is a gifted game manager. He wouldn't nearly be as successful here. Not even close.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He is a gifted game manager.

 

This.

 

You trade Russell Wilson for Cam and we don't even stand a chance the past two years with our defensive inconsistencies and O-line issues. And Wilson is my 2nd favorite QB to watch.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yeah really dumb idea. Star players will be getting thrown out for incidental contact that the ref "misunderstands" as a helmet shot. The solution isn't adding more rules or "being stricter" so to say but enforcing the rules that are already established down the middle. Our games are evidence enough that the refs suck but damn I got tired watching other teams play and see the game decided on either bullshit flags or lack of flags. If anybody needs to be punished more it isn't the players but these POS refs the league can't get their heads noses out of the asses of. Always an excuse or some convoluted reason why the refs were right. I actually heard the announcers calling it out tons of these obvious blown calls and yet still the league stands behind the refs like idiots.
    • First I got to say, damn, people trying to instantly make us the most hated team in the league, even over the Patriots aren't they lol. With all the hate Cam already gets then add Kap even if briefly, oh lord I'd hate to picture it. Yeah that first play is what stands out to me the most. I'd expect even a rookie QB to make that read and throw the ball instead of handing it off. That drive ended up in a safety where as if he throws it to Torrey Smith it is easily a 1st down and possibly a TD as he only has to beat one man. I don't even see Kap look around any in that clip so even more so it feels like he gave it away that it was a run play and the Rams read it like a book. I don't feel like we need him nor do I feel like he is better than what we have. As for his protest, I didn't like what he was doing when he was kneeling but hey he had the right to do it. I personally think him putting his money where his mouth was, was a better way than just kneeling and I commend him for doing so. To be honest the 49'ers have said they would welcome him back. Let's not forget he would still be with them had he not voided his own contract. Somebody will sign him though I just don't see it as a starter which is what he clearly wanted to try and be by voiding with the 49'ers.
    • I feel like this is some kind of guilty admission lol and you should feel bad for voting for that Lunatic / traitor president of ours.    But guess what, you will get a chance to redeem yourself in 2020 with more information about the disgraced president  coming out every week.