PFF ranks Ginn higher than Smitty

[TheRed 20,739]

I haven't watched much this year outside if my 3rd ranked Tigers and the Chickens of Columbia.

Sammy has a big week this week? He will probably require some Julio Jones type deal bc I think he will explode I he gets over this hump. FSU is a big stock game for him. They give him a chance to show of he has improved against legit physical CB play

 

I'd really like to get a taller receiver. There are some 6-4+ guys.

[CRA 13,936]

I'd really like to get a taller receiver. There are some 6-4+ guys.

Kid that plays with Johnny Football is a big boy. Some have him rated higher than Sammy.

[TheRumGone 14,893]

smitty's yardage will go drastically down but his tds i believe will be in the 6- 8 range

[TheRed 20,739]

Kid that plays with Johnny Football is a big boy. Some have him rated higher than Sammy.

 

Yup, Mike Evans. I would definitely love to have him, but I don't see that happening. Unless we want to give up half our draft.

[CelticCat 324]

Ginn has taken advantage of his opportunities and the deep routes hauling in 2 bombs with 0 drops attributed. I only recall 1 slightly overthrown ball he kinda alligator armed.

 

Smitty seems to be running the shorter routes and has a couple drops and finally got a TD last game. But he still gets the attention of the #1 DB.

 

Whats that they say about great QB making WR's look good. Ginn looks revitalised for a guy that could barely get a look in in SF and ran outta Miami.

[Darth Biscuit 12,771]

What's the 2014 WR draft class looking like?

 

 

Who is our scouting dept?  Panthers have been woefully inept at drafting offensive talent outside of round 1.

[natty 555]

I'd really like to get a taller receiver. There are some 6-4+ guys.

 

I don't care how tall, I want some speed.  Take advantage of Cam's arm.  

[thefuzz 4,814]

He is for a reason.  He is playing better this year.

 

Ginn is looking for one more paycheck, and knows that he has to show improvement to get it.

 

Smitty is aging, but still a threat.

[PhillyB 43,044]

they are playing different roles on the team right now. difficult comparison to make IMO

[OneBadCat 2,340]

A couple drops and bad Cam throws has made Smith look worse than he's really playing right now.

 

That said I think our WR core works in a very delicate complimentary fashion right now. We need a couple more deep bombs completed to really open things up for everyone.

[TheRed 20,739]

Who is our scouting dept?  Panthers have been woefully inept at drafting offensive talent outside of round 1.

 

If I recall, it is the same group from when Hurney was here, Gettleman kept them all on. Or should I say, JR did.  :cool:

FOOTBALL OPERATIONS:

Dave Gettleman: General Manager

Brandon Beane: Director of Football Operations

Don Gregory: Director of College Scouting

Mark Koncz: Director of Pro Scouting

Ryan Vermillion: Head Athletic Trainer

[Razeyfingers 1,005]

I have been holding my tongue on this subject and I cant say much. This how it is, every year many doubt Smitty can still play at a high level and every year they are wrong. With the acceleration in his step lacking the same punch its making it difficult for him to get separation. . . but he is still the smartest wr out there, he's still very athletic, and he still dole's out punishment to anyone that gets in his way.

 

the fact that he instinctively is always in a better place to make a play on the ball than Ginn should tell you who should be starting. . . . for now.