Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

top dawg

Cam haters, what you should have learned from the last 3 games

258 posts in this topic

somewhat different scenarios between Cam and Rivera..  

 

I hope Rivera stays the course and continues to get his team to show up on gameday.    

The criticism is much the same.  Newton is a third year quarterback.  Rivera is a third year head coach.  Both are learning and still figuring things out.  Both make mistakes.  Go ask the players about Rivera.  They love him and play hard for him every week.  They didn't give up last year and are working hard to help him save his job this year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The criticism is much the same.  Newton is a third year quarterback.  Rivera is a third year head coach.  Both are learning and still figuring things out.  Both make mistakes.  

 

Out of curiosity, how many years experience do our coach and QB need before we can  start asking for a playoff appearance?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The criticism is much the same.  Newton is a third year quarterback.  Rivera is a third year head coach.  Both are learning and still figuring things out.  Both make mistakes.  Go ask the players about Rivera.  They love him and play hard for him every week.  They didn't give up last year and are working hard to help him save his job this year.

 

on the surface, I would agree..

 

I just think the vindictive attacks on Cam are much different than those who are simply ready to move on from Rivera.

 

one guy has proven throughout 3 years he'll give your team a chance to win more often than not.  the other guy has given fans a lot of tragic 4th quarter losses to store in the memory bank.

 

just seems the criticism from Cam is far more unwarranted due to the type of people constantly ready to attack him.  I don't think that's the same for Rivera.  

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Out of curiosity, how many years experience do our coach and QB need before we can  start asking for a playoff appearance?

Depends on the circumstances.  When Cam and Rivera came here we had little talent on this team.  Each year we have increased it to the point that this year we are at least in the conversation at this point. Some coaches like Reid inherited a pretty talented team and have turned it around right away.  It also depends on whether you have a seasoned coach or quarterback or you pick rookies at both positions.  Both Rivera and Newton were rookies at their position and have needed time to learn. That is the price you pay when you have guys who need to learn as you go.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

on the surface, I would agree..

 

I just think the vindictive attacks on Cam are much different than those who are simply ready to move on from Rivera.

 

one guy has proven throughout 3 years he'll give your team a chance to win more often than not.  the other guy has given fans a lot of tragic 4th quarter losses to store in the memory bank.

 

just seems the criticism from Cam is far more unwarranted due to the type of people constantly ready to attack him.  I don't think that's the same for Rivera.  

Depends on who you talk to.  Many experts I have read or heard talk about Rivera say the attacks on Rivera are unwarranted as well and sing his praises. Some criticize him.  I guess it depends on who you listen to and what you already believe to color your opinion.   Pretty much the same with Cam.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Happy Panther, on 23 Oct 2013 - 09:39 AM, said:

We are prisoners of the moment. 

 

My analysis is that Cam has struggled against real pressure and excelled when he has time. I think the O-Line has certainly looked better but I am not convinced they are ready to stand up to top 10 defenses. We have lost to 

Sea (ranked 1) 

Buf (6)

Ari (5)

 

Newton looked terrible in two of those but actually managed the game well against Seattle.

 

We have beaten

NYG (23)

MIN (25)

STL (27)

 

Teams we may struggle against if my theory holds

TB x2 (9)

NE (8)

NYJ (4) 

SF (10)

 

That is 5 games and we can only lose three while beating everyone else to get to the playoffs. If we are beating these teams behind Cam's arm I will drink the kool-aid. Otherwise I remain prepared to look back at 8-8 yet again.

 

 

Great post. I think we have to go 5-1 in the division and some how manage 2-1 in the NE SF MIA stretch to have a shot. NYJ scares me as well. At least it's a home game.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Depends on the circumstances.  When Cam and Rivera came here we had little talent on this team.  Each year we have increased it to the point that this year we are at least in the conversation at this point. Some coaches like Reid inherited a pretty talented team and have turned it around right away.  It also depends on whether you have a seasoned coach or quarterback or you pick rookies at both positions.  Both Rivera and Newton were rookies at their position and have needed time to learn. That is the price you pay when you have guys who need to learn as you go.

 

If we thought Rivera was not NFL ready we should not have hired him. If Cam wasn't NFL ready then you don't use a #1 pick on him. All teams hire guys who can make an impact very soon. Rivera has been a coach in the league for 14 years.

 

Rivera already got lucky to have a third year here. Losing coaches don't last any longer that that.

 

We have the talent right now to be a playoff team. Going 6-10 to 7-9 to say 8-8 can't just be blamed on a learning curve.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Depends on who you talk to.  Many experts I have read or heard talk about Rivera say the attacks on Rivera are unwarranted as well and sing his praises. Some criticize him.  I guess it depends on who you listen to and what you already believe to color your opinion.   Pretty much the same with Cam.

 

I'm speaking manly about people on the forum since that was what I originally meant...  

 

often people will show up when the defense loses the game at the end and blame Cam.  With Rivera, there's a little more to pull from than firing shots in any direction.

 

Good news is he got this team to play better before the season was over.  I hope that continues as the schedule gets tougher.

 

 

I do agree there are examples where players were put in position to succeed and Rivera still catches a lot of flack..  aside from that though..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we thought Rivera was not NFL ready we should not have hired him. If Cam wasn't NFL ready then you don't use a #1 pick on him. All teams hire guys who can make an impact very soon. Rivera has been a coach in the league for 14 years.

 

Rivera already got lucky to have a third year here. Losing coaches don't last any longer that that.

 

We have the talent right now to be a playoff team. Going 6-10 to 7-9 to say 8-8 can't just be blamed on a learning curve.

That is a conversation you need to have with JR.  He picked Rivera because the NFL veteran head coaches wanted complete say in operations and Rivera would do what he told.  Plus how many coaches were dying to take over a 2-14 team who were decimated of talent??

 

As for Cam, no one thought he was ready to start but given his athleticism and potential he was deemed the right guy for the future.  And in that respect they might have been right.

 

I don't think anyone thinks we shouldn't make the playoffs this year.  But a learning curve can't be denied either.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm by no means a Cam hater, but it feel like every year Cam has a stretch of a great couple of game, and then lays an egg.

You just described every QB in the NFL....except for those that have no stretches of good games and guys named Peyton Manning (this year).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.