Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

PntherPryd

Newton Blog; Smith on Chud (again)

51 posts in this topic

Thanks CSX this doesn't prove anything and they barely lost TOP but good job

 

They have one of the lowest TOPs in the league. Sometimes a discussion doesn't have to be about proving anything. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They have one of the lowest TOPs in the league. Sometimes a discussion doesn't have to be about proving anything.

And sometimes the discussion completely takes a wrong turn when you're at the wheel while I'm simply pointing out that Smith was off by like 25 points

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really really do wish we had gordon

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Still possible for him to go over 1k but he'll have to avg 100 yds a game from here on out and he doesnt even have 1 100 yard performance this year

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Smitty needs some stats.....

 

He needs postseason stats and a ring.  Regular season stats at this point don't mean much for having a shot at the HOF IMO..

Compared to his contemporaries, #89 has triple the receiving yards in the postseason than Andre Johnson and is on par with Larry Fitzgerald in yards and touchdowns.

 

Steve also has more combined yards than the other two and none of the three have any rings. 

 

If Steve doesn't make it then neither should the other two.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Compared to his contemporaries, #89 has triple the receiving yards in the postseason than Andre Johnson and is on par with Larry Fitzgerald in yards and touchdowns.

 

Steve also has more combined yards than the other two and none of the three have any rings. 

 

If Steve doesn't make it then neither should the other two.

it will be hard for Andre Johnson type WRs to get....there will such a log jam of WRs of his caliber.

 

Steve was on pace to have a historical postseason resume.....he needs to go back to adding to it to get into the HOF IMO.

 

Fitzgerald has better numbers than 89 right now....that gives him an edge (regular and post)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it will be hard for Andre Johnson type WRs to get....there will such a log jam of WRs of his caliber.

 

Steve was on pace to have a historical postseason resume.....he needs to go back to adding to it to get into the HOF IMO.

It seems to me though that most reports that I see is that Larry and Andre are locks for the HOF while Smitty is on the outside of the fence. I just don't see why when the numbers don't support it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It seems to me though that most reports that I see is that Larry and Andre are locks for the HOF while Smitty is on the outside of the fence. I just don't see why when the numbers don't support it.

numbers support Fitz over 89

 

Johnson I don't believe belongs on the talk with either

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Steve says a lot of things he probably shouldn't. What he said is true but is it really necessary to keep blasting your former coach publicly.

Steve is no longer a dominant player and it comes across as him not being able to accept himself as an average WR at age 34. It's like he has to give excuses as to why he is no longer putting up All Pro numbers.

However, the next day he'll go on the radio and talk about how he enjoys taking a back seat to the younger guys now and is just doing his part to help the team win.

Complete mind fug.

Disclaimer:

Before everyone comes running to call me an idiot and defend Steve like an overprotective mother, Steve Smith is, and will always be, my favorite athlete. I love that guy and want to see him finish his career here and play as long as he wants. He deserves a Super Bowl ring and I hope he gets one here. That said, he isn't perfect. He still says dumb stuff. Blast away.

 

Who is Ryan Kalil?

 

 

nuff said...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

how larry gets in over smith i don't know.........different note smith gets open and separation lol he kills his own yardage when he does a half spin into 3 defenders lol plus he doesn't get as much targets

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • You do realize no one wanted RyanCare/ObamaCare Lite to pass, right? If anything, the media and democrats has made themselves absolute fools lately. STILL no evidence Trump colluded with Russia whatsoever, which is quite the funny irony in this whole conspiracy. Trump inherited a mess. Hard to fix this mess when you got crybaby globalists and dems everywhere.    
    • I hate this DG analogy so much.  It only makes sense in the context of an efficient market where teams are rational, have perfect information, and scouts are always right about players.  But we have ample evidence that is not the case.  Sometimes, talented players just don't work out.  Injuries derail careers.  Teams make oddball picks.  Sometimes, you are just wrong about a player (see Ealy, Kony). I like him a lot, but DG's habit of always trading up / never trading down may ultimately be his downfall in CAR.  It results in a lack of depth across the roster and it makes your roster very vulnerable to i) injuries (see 2015 vs. 2016) and ii) missing on evals.  If we missed on Funchess (jury still out), that hurts - but missing on Funchess when you traded multiple picks to get him compounds the issue. Trading up and trading down are both valid strategies - but I'd suggest balancing the two strategies would improve your chances of long-term success.
    • He is worth #8 pick. I'd like to see him next to Newton on the field.