...were you and I watching the same game?
since you want to put so many weird caveat's on Cam's performance, don't forget to remove Geno's biggest passing play too, and keep in mind that something like 70 of Geno's total yards came on the last drive when the Panthers were basically playing prevent and forcing them to eat clock.
the two were not in the same league out there for most of the game... but that doesn't mean Geno has no future in the NFL.
"ha ha, this guy isn't really that good if you wipe all the game changing plays made by other units out!"
how could any thinking person think that's a good argument or a sensible position to take. i can understand the newton vs. luck circle jerk because those two are at least somewhat comparable physically and they were both top picks in the draft but this geno smith thing is baffling to me.
of course this is mr. "derek anderson would have led this team to 10-4 too" talking so who knows.