Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Giants letting Nicks walk!

387 posts in this topic

Posted · Report post

No, we don't decide anything here. The real decisions belong to the front office.

 

I doubt we will sign Cooper. I just don't think he's going to be exiled from the NFL because of the idiotic comment he made at a country music concert. He's got talent, so he's going to get paid by someone.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Personality plays a big part in football, fitting into a locker room matters. Cooper's past will follow him, whether people such as CarolinaCoolin, or Icebox like it or not.

I'm sure Cooper has said racist things like that before amongst his friends, he just happened to get caught that time, he showed himself for what he truly is. If he hadn't been videotaped, exposed, and forced to apologize because his career was in jeopardy, he wouldn't have given a damn.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

[quote name="pantherclaw" post="2618873" timestamp="1389896647"]
Andre could end up being a casualty due to the Texans cap.

How would you feel about Andre Johnson in Carolina blue?[/quote]

I would trade hardy and a pick for him

Bring him in!!!!!!! Thought about that idea months ago already.

I'd be fine with sacrificing Hardy to get him. Smitty, Ginn, Olsen and Johnson would be a pretty frigging good receiving corp.

who wouldnt want him?

One year deal Gettleman style? HELL YES. He could be our Anquan Boldin.

God.

Andre and Smitty.

fug everything else.

I'd definitely sign him

BRUCE-LEE-APPROVES-GIF.gif

AJ would solidify us as a elite team

Get rid of Hardy in order to sign someone like Johnson? Hell to the yeah

Expecting even half the impact from a rookie is a pipe dream.



first 5 seasons:

games missed:

Andre: 10
Nicks: 10

totals/averages:

Andre: 371 Rec, 4804 Yd, 25 TD
Nicks: 311 Rec, 4622 Yd, 27 TD

Andre: 74.2 Rec, 960.8 Yd, 5.0 TD
Nicks: 62.2 Rec, 924.4 Yd, 5.4 TD

Playoff totals/averages:

Andre: N/A
Nicks: 28 Rec, 444 Yd, 4 TD

Andre: N/A
Nicks: 7 Rec, 111 Yd, 1 TD

Both guys are big, physical receivers with great hands. Both guys missed the same number of games and had very, very similar production their first 5 seasons. Yet the huddle wants the expensive 33-year old, not the 26-year old who is cheaper. Not to mention he is a Super Bowl Champion with Smitty-esque playoff numbers.

I love this place.
4 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

somebody is going to throw a shitload of cash at him and I doubt it will be the Panthers. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

 

 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 




first 5 seasons:

games missed:

Andre: 10
Nicks: 10

totals:

Andre: 371 Rec, 4804 Yd, 25 TD
Nicks: 311 Rec, 4622 Yd, 27 TD

averages:

Andre: 74.2 Rec, 960.8 Yd, 5.0 TD
Nicks: 62.2 Rec, 924.4 Yd, 5.4 TD


Both guys are big, physical receivers with great hands. Both guys missed the same number of games and had very, very similar production their first 5 seasons. Yet the huddle wants the expensive 33-year old version, not the 26-year old cheaper version.

I love this place.

 

I wouldn't mind either one... So I don't know why you included me in this O.o 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

 

 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 




first 5 seasons:

games missed:

Andre: 10
Nicks: 10

totals:

Andre: 371 Rec, 4804 Yd, 25 TD
Nicks: 311 Rec, 4622 Yd, 27 TD

averages:

Andre: 74.2 Rec, 960.8 Yd, 5.0 TD
Nicks: 62.2 Rec, 924.4 Yd, 5.4 TD


Both guys are big, physical receivers with great hands. Both guys missed the same number of games and had very, very similar production their first 5 seasons. Yet the huddle wants the expensive 33-year old version, not the 26-year old cheaper version.

I love this place.

 

Wow. You do realize Andre Johnson played with David Carr for four of those years in an era where you didn't throw as much, right? Why not compare what they've done while playing at the same time?

Andre Johnson - 441 Rec, 6282 Yd, 28 TD (68 GP/GS)

Hakeem Nicks - 311 Rec, 4,622, 27 TD (70 GP, 59 GS)

Averages (per season):

Andre Johnson - 88 Rec, 1257 Yd, 6 TD

Hakeem Nicks - 62 Rec, 924 Yd, 5 TD

That guy has carved an amazing career and never had a great quarterback - he's just like Steve Smith in that regard. He elevates the talent around him, and I just don't think Hakeem Nicks can do that... that said, I'd be fine with either, but I'd only sacrifice Hardy for Andre Johnson.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Wow. You do realize Andre Johnson played with David Carr for four of those years in an era where you didn't throw as much, right? Why not compare what they've done while playing at the same time?

Andre Johnson - 441 Rec, 6282 Yd, 28 TD (68 GP/GS)
Hakeem Nicks - 311 Rec, 4,622, 27 TD (70 GP, 59 GS)

Averages (per season):
Andre Johnson - 88 Rec, 1257 Yd, 6 TD
Hakeem Nicks - 62 Rec, 924 Yd, 5 TD
That guy has carved an amazing career and never had a great quarterback - he's just like Steve Smith in that regard. He elevates the talent around him, and I just don't think Hakeem Nicks can do that... that said, I'd be fine with either, but I'd only sacrifice Hardy for Andre Johnson.

Yes, Andre Johnson played with David Carr. What's your point? Hakeem Nicks had to play with Eli Manning who just had a season worst than David Carr ever had.

Regardless, I don't see how you think it's fair to compare a guy in his prime to a guy just entering the league. That's hilarious.

Do you wanna compare Cam's last 3 seasons to Peyton Manning while you're at it?
1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

if the panthers could get Nicks on a decent contract, i wouldnt be mad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Yes, Andre Johnson played with David Carr. What's your point? Hakeem Nicks had to play with Eli Manning who just had a season worst than David Carr ever had.

Regardless, I don't see how you think it's fair to compare a guy in his prime to a guy just entering the league. That's hilarious.

Do you wanna compare Cam's last 3 seasons to Peyton Manning while you're at it?

 

How many Super Bowls has Eli Manning won, and how many times did David Carr make the playoffs?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Clear and Objective. Forget the pie get this guy the bakery.

Of course you will still get some in here that have minds like bricks and instead of opening up they would rather find something, anything, to retain their hard opinion.


first 5 seasons:

games missed:

Andre: 10
Nicks: 10

totals:

Andre: 371 Rec, 4804 Yd, 25 TD
Nicks: 311 Rec, 4622 Yd, 27 TD

averages:

Andre: 74.2 Rec, 960.8 Yd, 5.0 TD
Nicks: 62.2 Rec, 924.4 Yd, 5.4 TD


Both guys are big, physical receivers with great hands. Both guys missed the same number of games and had very, very similar production their first 5 seasons. Yet the huddle wants the expensive 33-year old version, not the 26-year old cheaper version.

I love this place.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

How many Super Bowls has Eli Manning won, and how many times did David Carr make the playoffs?


Eli Manning has won two Super Bowls, but so has David Carr. What is your point?
1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Let's compare Carr's stats his 4 seasons with Andre to Eli's stats his last 4 seasons with Nicks.

Carr: 62.1% completions (1010 of 1626)
Eli : 60.3% completions (1336 of 2215)

Carr: 50 interceptions (3.1% INT rate)
Eli : 83 interceptions (3.8% INT rate)

Thanks for making another argument for signing Nicks.
1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites