Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

I sense a lot of doubt

69 posts in this topic

Posted

I never said he didn't deserve any credit, I said he doesn't deserve as much credit as you guys here give him. I also never said I preferred Marty as a GM, those are assumptions you must include because your argument is void of anything that makes sense.

And again I hate to defend Hurney, but getting a GM job ain't easy ol Dave will tell you that. Who says he's even looking for a job? He might be content where he is.

Given the posts you've made lately - including the one I responded to - you're not really in much of a position to talk about the other people's arguments not making sense.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

U didn't answer any of his questions. Just made fun of him.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

His point is that people on here are screaming patience, yet jump all over gman like he is the coming of Jesus. We must have been so starved for a winner! My question is still the same if he gets all the credit for 12-4, if we don't do good this year, he should also get all the blame.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

How some of you can't wait to blame DG when it's clear he doesn't have the money to acquire quality talent is amazing. Yes we are saying give him credit for being able to get some good players for cheap last year but if we don't have the same result this year ( as a result of Hurney leaving us in cap hell) how are you going to blame him? Where was he supposed to get the money from?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

His point is that people on here are screaming patience, yet jump all over gman like he is the coming of Jesus. We must have been so starved for a winner! My question is still the same if he gets all the credit for 12-4, if we don't do good this year, he should also get all the blame.

 

All the blame?

 

Did he write all the contracts that are on the books right now?

 

Until the answer to that question is 'yes', then 'all the blame' isn't really going to be a valid option.  And no, neither is 'all the credit' but the more rational posters on here would tell you he he deserves way more of it than Mr. Boogie is giving.

 

Nobody is 'jumping all over Gman like he's the second coming'.  What we are saying is that he's a true "football guy" and the Panthers are finally being run like a true football team.  And that is something that's worthy of a little patience.

 

That is, unless you wanna be one of those teams that just fires whomever's in charge when they don't win it all.  That's the philosophy that's been employed by teams like the Raiders and the Browns.

 

How's that approach working in those cities?

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

All the blame?

Did he write all the contracts that are on the books right now?

Until the answer to that question is 'yes', then 'all the blame' isn't really going to be a valid option. And no, neither is 'all the credit' but the more rational posters on here would tell you he he deserves way more of it than Mr. Boogie is giving.

Nobody is 'jumping all over Gman like he's the second coming'. What we are saying is that he's a true "football guy" and the Panthers are finally being run like a true football team. And that is something that's worthy of a little patience.

That is, unless you wanna be one of those teams that just fires whomever's in charge when they don't win it all. That's the philosophy that's been employed by teams like the Raiders and the Browns.

How's that approach working in those cities?

Gettleman deserves credit for getting under the cap,(which is something every GM can do)while maintaining a competitive roster(something not every GM can do).In other words Gettleman brought in the side dishes to the thanksgiving feast to complete the meal. The turkey was already here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Gettleman deserves credit for getting under the cap,(which is something every GM can do)while maintaining a competitive roster(something not every GM can do).In other words Gettleman brought in the side dishes to the thanksgiving feast to complete the meal. The turkey was already here.

 

And that was so easy anyone could do it, right?

 

(except the guy who said, "I don't know" of course)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

And that was so easy anyone could do it, right?

(except the guy who said, "I don't know" of course)

He said I don't know to why the record was it was. Let's not forget we were 1-3 this year until Ron became Riverboat Ron. I'm not a Hurney fan, I wanted the guy fired lets make that clear. Just because you don't agree with the moves Gettleman makes doesn't mean you want Hurney back.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Hurney obviously deserved to be fired, largely for his terrible drafting outside the first round.

Gettleman inherited some damn fine pieces roster wise though. Cam, Luke, CJ, Hardy, Kalil, Olsen, Davis.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Every year it's the same thing, I've done it myself, we sit here and complain about the previous season and doom the next. We don't know what will happen. It's okay to express your displeasure with the previous season. But my God let all the offseason (ie: draft and fee agency) happen before we call the next season a Bust. C'mon man!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Again I not saying DG is a bad gm. I am just saying let's give him more than a year before we bow down to him. Most in the NFL will tell you one year may not necessarily carry over to the next. So what worked magically for him last year may not work as well this year.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Again I not saying DG is a bad gm. I am just saying let's give him more than a year before we bow down to him. Most in the NFL will tell you one year may not necessarily carry over to the next. So what worked magically for him last year may not work as well this year.

 

Nobody's bowing down to him.

 

What we are saying is essentially four things...

 

- Late March / early April is way too soon for panic, doom and gloom, regardless of who the GM is. 

 

- Gettleman did a good job last year, so he's earned the benefit of a doubt going into this season. 

 

- There are limitations and constraints placed on him because of Hurney's mismanagement that he'll have to fight through

 

- Until the bad contracts written by Hurney are off the books, you can't put all the blame for anything on Gettleman

 

Bottom Line: Free agency will be continuing for a few months yet and we haven't even gotten close to the draft.  There's still plenty of offseason left.  For that reason alone, the people screaming and throwing tantrums about the state of the roster right now are being utterly ridiculous.

 

No 'bowing down to Gettleman'.  it's just a matter of being at least a halfway rational adult.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites