most VALUABLE player... when your talking about value, your looking for the player that gives you the most bang for your buck. that has to be Cam, Luke, or Star... all 3 on rookie contracts making veteran plays. Tell me a player in the NFL that gives you more value for less money than those 3.
OPY is another story entirely. id def put manning n that list.
Valuable as in valuable to the team, not a "bargain value" salary wise. If that were the case, rookies would win MVP every season.