We're talking about practice, man. We're talking about practice. We're not even talking about a game.
We're not even talking about practice really. It's a starting point to learn the system and get your feet wet. I'm not going to throw the towel in on a guy because he has a couple of shitty OTAs.
Who is throwing the towel in on him? I am simply saying he looks awful in OTA's which will translate to him looking really awful once the pads are on in camp. His feet are extremely slow, Johnson and Hardy will eat him alive. He is a 3 year project minimum.
You wanting him to compete right now at tackle is nuts.
The Panthers need to fill a huge hole left by Ted Ginn in the punt return game. Ginn was the first legitimate threat the Panthers had had in many seasons, replacing him won't be easy.
Yesterday at OTA's the order of punt returners went as follows:
Antoine Cason Marvin McNutt Philly Brown De'Andre Presley
Cason and McNutt got the majority of the punts. The other two fielded at the end of the drill.
Antoine Cason returned punts in San Diego for the last several games of the 2010 season. Then San Diego Defensive Coordinator Ron Rivera must have taken note. This could be Cason's real purpose this season. Cason returned punts in college, running back two for touchdowns. He is the front runner for the spot.
As far as I can tell, McNutt has no punt return experience.
Philly Brown is a promising prospect at punt returner. He could be fast enough and shifty enough to win the job. He also does have experience, including this run back against Wisconsin. I can see him competing with Cason.
De'Andre Presley, who played QB, WR, CB and also returned punts at App State has an outside shot, but will need more snaps to impress. He was last in line to return, and only had a single grab.