Jump to content


Member Since 06 Sep 2009
Last Active Apr 06 2015 05:41 PM

Topics I've Started

Film Room with Cam Newton.

02 January 2015 - 08:41 AM

Football Outsiders break down Cam Newton's development in the pocket this season, specifically looking at the Browns game.

Sorry about that. Phone didn't post the link I wanted. For clarification:

Possibly the worst draft ever:

Story I was actually talking about:


What We Do and Do Not Have (8-23-14).

23 August 2014 - 05:32 AM

It seems like a lot of people are worked up about that preseason game. The final score looked bad, and the game was rough at times, but anybody who saw that game as a "revelation" has not been or isn't paying attention. I think we can sit up in the sober light of dawn (even though it's not dawn yet) and say a couple things:


We do have a Franchise Quarterback.


We have a quarterback that plays through injuries, rust, and pressure in a PRESEASON GAME. A lot of other guys would have shut it down after that shot to the ribs. Cam Newton is a man and a leader who looks like he might be developing further as a passer this offseason.


We do not have a Perfect Quarterback.


Tom Brady accurately, consistently, and with variation drove his team down field. He is one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, if not the greatest of all time. Cam doesn't look that good because, maybe, five guys have been that good. Ever. Tom Brady is also approaching forty and hasn't won a superbowl since before Terrell Owens was a laughing stock. Cam was not perfect tonight, but he was better than a vast majority of quarterbacks would have been. Valid criticism is important, but appreciating what you have and what your opponent is too.


We have a great young receiver in Kelvin Benjamin.


Benjamin came into the league with much more polish and ability than many draft experts thought. It already looks like we got a steal with our pick and many teams will regret passing on him. Credit to Cam and Ricky Proehl for working with him so much, but also credit Benjamin for working so hard to be ready now. The future at wideout looks bright for the first time in a while.


We do not have great depth at receiver.


Cotchery and Avant are nothing special, and none of the young guys outside of Benjamin will give us a ton this year. Philly Brown may be a average punt returner, which is way more than I expected from any of these guys. We are lucky so many people were wrong about Benjamin because we would struggle to get separation anywhere if not for him and Olsen. One of Cotchery or Avant will probably develop into a inconsistent but passable option like Lafell was last year. Frustrating at times, but enough for us to get by on.


We do have a young left tackle that struggles with speed rushers.


Byron Bell has been a steal. To get that kind of play from an UDFA is amazing, but we know what he is. We have known for years. For some people to pretend he was suddenly going to turn a corner this season and become an entirely different player this season was silly.


We do not have the death of the 2014 season at left tackle.


In 2005, we moved an overmatched Travelle Wharton to left tackle. He was inconsistent, and at times downright terrible (six sacks given up to the Bears at Soldier Field, a game I skipped out on class and financial obligations to go see). He was also solid enough, consistently enough to give us a chance to win. From what I have seen, Byron Bell does not look much better or worse than Travelle did that season. So, hopefully, he is enough.


We do have a chance to have back to back winning seasons for the first time in franchise history.


There is enough talent on this team to make the playoffs. Newton, Davis, Kuechly, Benjamin, Olsen, Star, Johnson, Hardy, etc form an amazing, young nucleus that learned how to win last year. We will be dangerous this year, and better in years to come.


We do not have a guarantee to have back to back winning seasons.


It will not be a cake walk. We have enough holes on this team to regress to 8-8 or 7-9. But football is a weird, rarely predictable, game. So I would therefore encourage you to go to the games, cheer hard, and hope we get a few lucky breaks along the way.


Go Panthers.

Somebody Should Put Kuechly In Witness Protection.

01 July 2014 - 08:24 PM

Kiko Alonso, Sean Lee, Jon Beason, and Sean Weatherspoon? Somebody's knocking off inside linebackers, and he may be next.

Can Someone Explain Why Gettleman Loves Voidable Years to Me?

20 March 2014 - 05:22 PM

So. . . It spreads out the bonus money? And then after we "cut" them after two years instead of letting the deal expires, it moves some of the cap hit into future years? Is that it because it still seems like a lot of trouble for not that much gain.

Mike Tanier Picks Panthers, Writes Poetically About Smitty.

09 January 2014 - 11:08 AM




Steve Smith made playoff magic exactly one decade ago Friday. He caught six passes for 163 yards in a playoff upset of the Rams, including a 69-yard touchdown pass in double overtime -- the greatest play in the greatest game in Panthers history, and one of the greatest playoff games in NFL history.


Yes, that was the same Steve Smith, not his father or some other receiver with the same name. He was the star of a playoff game that featured Marshall Faulk and Orlando Pace, Stephen Davis and Jake Delhomme, Aeneas Williams and Dan Morgan and … believe it … JASON SEHORN. He has been in Carolina the whole time. He has changed, as Pearl Jam would say, by not changing much at all.



Smith is also the chronicler of Panthers history. He was there for double overtime, for Jake Delhomme's Arizona meltdown and Janet Jackson's nipple. He was there for 2-14, catching passes from Jimmy Clausen and Brian St. Pierre. He broke an arm scoring a touchdown that did nothing but edge the Panthers closer to .500. He welcomed Newton and challenged Newton, and the current Panthers have absorbed Smith's personality in a way that recent Ravens teams became extensions of Ray Lewis. The Panthers are dangerous, daring and scrappy, and they are not quite as new to the playoff picture as they appear.


Prediction: Panthers 23, 49ers 17


I love Tanier, and he was big on this team before the season. Hope his faith, and ours, gets rewarded on Sunday.