He hasn't once said the Panthers would end up with Samuel, so for you to set such lofty standards, is completely illogical.
Everything that he could be saying is true, even if the Panthers end up with nothing else.
That's the thing. Most of his predictions can't be proven wrong because they lack boldness. I could have made most of his predictions. The boldest things he said, albeit not about the Panthers, were completely wrong. I don't see why it's so unrealistic to not believe him unless there is some proof from another source that they were interested in Samuel.