Worst message board to discuss football? - Page 2

John Fox · 06-19-2009, 01:56 AM

AFMB by far and its not even a contest.

Bucs board is strict, but they are some cool people, most level headed (by far more than the Huddle)

I don't read saints report.

But AFMB is by far the worst of the worst. Here is how a typical topic looks like.

Poster#1: MATTRYANMATTRYANMATTRYANMATTRYANMATTRYANMATTRYANMA TTRYANMATTRYAN

Poster#2:
MATTRYAN? MVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVP.GOATGOATGO ATGOATGOATGOATGOAT

Poster#3:TURNERTURNERTURNERTURNERTURNERTURNERTURNE RTURNER

Oh, I forgot to add the sigs:

John Fox · 06-19-2009, 02:00 AM

So that's what a typical thread looks like at AFMB, sorry I raped your eyes. That place is like a train wreck, I don't want to look... but I just have to.

Savoir Faire · 06-19-2009, 11:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Fox

So that's what a typical thread looks like at AFMB, sorry I raped your eyes. That place is like a train wreck, I don't want to look... but I just have to.

About all I see different between that and here are the names (Williams/Beason vs Ryan/Turner) and the sigs.

PS: And I bet the names would be the only difference if sigs like that were allowed here.

koolkatluke · 06-19-2009, 11:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Savoir Faire

About all I see different between that and here are the names (Williams/Beason vs Ryan/Turner) and the sigs.

PS: And I bet the names would be the only difference if sigs like that were allowed here.

Atleast over here another fan bases can pretty much talk as much trash as he wants and not worry about getting banned.

koolkatluke · 06-19-2009, 11:59 AM

The buc board is really good.

Falcons1stPanthers2nd · 06-19-2009, 12:01 PM

If you stay out of TATF then the AFMB is actually really good. As for me i can't stand Saintsreport.

Darth Hater · 06-19-2009, 12:38 PM

Saintsreport is pretty bad. their are a lot of delusional fans that feel as though they deserve to play every game at home "in the dome". I wish I had a quarter for every time I read the phrase "in the dome" when those tools are discussing a loss. Most of them don't realize football was invented in the elements to be played in the elements. There's a lot of butt hurt Bears haters over there too which makes it pretty funny. Entire threads dedicated to the hatred of a team that doesn't even play in their division.

Falcons1stPanthers2nd · 06-19-2009, 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darth Hater

Saintsreport is pretty bad. their are a lot of delusional fans that feel as though they deserve to play every game at home "in the dome". I wish I had a quarter for every time I read the phrase "in the dome" when those tools are discussing a loss. Most of them don't realize football was invented in the elements to be played in the elements. There's a lot of butt hurt Bears haters over there too which makes it pretty funny. Entire threads dedicated to the hatred of a team that doesn't even play in their division.

Have to remember that was the furthest they ever got in the playoffs and you destroyed all hope they had.

Skew · 06-19-2009, 10:27 PM

I had to think about it for a while. And since I'm a mod here, I will give my opinion without including the Huddle compared to the other three boards to avoid any bias.

I will give each board a grade of 1 -3 based on several factors, with 1 being the worst and 3 being the best. In each category, one team has to get a 1 vote, one team has to get a 2 vote, and one team has to get a 3 vote. Let's see how each does with the following categories for the Pewter Report board, Atlanta Falcons Message Board, and the Saints Board (pick one). So the highest score is the best.

Shall we?

Categories are:

Professionalism of board
Intellegence of posters
Intellegence of mods/admins
Posting of new NFL news
How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against the norm.
How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a player who has committed a crime.
How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a mod/admin.
How quickly a rival fan will be gang banged by other board members for having a different thought from the regular board members.

"SHALL WE PLAY A GAME?"

Professionalism of board
Falcons 1
Saints 2
Bucs 3

Intellegence of posters
Falcons 1
Saints 2
Bucs 3

Intellegence of mods/admins
Falcons 1
Bucs 2
Saints 3

Posting of new NFL news
Saints 1
Falcons 2
Bucs 3

How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against the norm.
Bucs 1
Falcons 2
Saints 3

How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a player who has committed a crime.
Falcons 1
Bucs 2
Saints 3

How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a mod/admin.

Bucs 1
Falcons 2
Saints 3

How quickly a rival fan will be gang banged by other board members for having a different thought from the regular board members.

Bucs 1
Saints 2
Falcons 3

Bonus points:
Mods/Admins I've met from other boards who have made a positive influence on me can earn extra points. (Remember, this is my personal opinion, and by no means represents the official opinion of the Carolina Huddle).

And the the final score is:

Bucs: 16
Saints: 19
Falcons: 13

Bonusus points: I've met the mods for the Falcons board and they are just as much of idiots as their posters are, so that's -5 points. I'm surprised they scored that high.

I was surprised that the Saints came out on top but I think that most people don't expect too many intellegent Saints fans to throw a curve in the grading.

I would have thought the bucs would have come out on top.

Anyway, try it yourself, exempting your team an see how it turns out.

Skew

Falcons1stPanthers2nd · 06-19-2009, 10:35 PM

Professionalism of board
Panthers 1
Saints 2
Bucs 3

Intelligence of posters
Saints 1
Panthers 2
Bucs 3

Intellegence of mods/admins
Bucs 1
Panthers 2
Saints 3

Posting of new NFL news
Saints 1
Bucs 2
Panthers 3

How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against the norm.
Bucs 1
Saints 2
Panthers 3

How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a player who has committed a crime.
Bucs 1
Saints 2
Panthers 3

How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a mod/admin.

Bucs 1
Saints 2
Panthers 3

How quickly a rival fan will be gang banged by other board members for having a different thought from the regular board members.

Panthers 1
Bucs 2
Saints 3

Panthers-18
Saints-16
Bucs-14

I'd switch the Saints and Bucs but yeah.

View Poll Results: Worst Message Board to Discuss Football?
buccaneers forum	4	7.84%
falcons life	18	35.29%
Saints report	19	37.25%
carolinahuddle	10	19.61%
Voters: 51. You may not vote on this poll

06-19-2009, 01:56 AM	#11
John Fox it is what it is Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 1,427 Pie Slices: 6 Given Pie 11 Times in 5 Posts Rep Power: 0	AFMB by far and its not even a contest. Bucs board is strict, but they are some cool people, most level headed (by far more than the Huddle) I don't read saints report. But AFMB is by far the worst of the worst. Here is how a typical topic looks like. Poster#1: MATTRYANMATTRYANMATTRYANMATTRYANMATTRYANMATTRYANMA TTRYANMATTRYAN Poster#2: MATTRYAN? MVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVPMVP.GOATGOATGO ATGOATGOATGOATGOAT Poster#3:TURNERTURNERTURNERTURNERTURNERTURNERTURNE RTURNER Oh, I forgot to add the sigs: __________________ JBRO YOU cotton headed ninny muggin FREE FOX Last edited by John Fox; 06-19-2009 at 01:59 AM.

06-19-2009, 02:00 AM	#12
John Fox it is what it is Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 1,427 Pie Slices: 6 Given Pie 11 Times in 5 Posts Rep Power: 0	So that's what a typical thread looks like at AFMB, sorry I raped your eyes. That place is like a train wreck, I don't want to look... but I just have to. __________________ JBRO YOU cotton headed ninny muggin FREE FOX

06-19-2009, 11:59 AM	#15
koolkatluke Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2008 Posts: 699 Pie Slices: 0 Given Pie 1 Time in 1 Post Rep Power: 3	The buc board is really good. __________________ The Sum of all Fears

06-19-2009, 12:01 PM	#16
Falcons1stPanthers2nd Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 1,582 Pie Slices: 0 Given Pie 0 Times in 0 Posts Rep Power: 5	If you stay out of TATF then the AFMB is actually really good. As for me i can't stand Saintsreport. __________________ RIP to all who died at Pearl Harbor. You shall not be forgotten. RIP Great Uncle Herbert.

06-19-2009, 12:38 PM	#17
Darth Hater Sunnyvale senior member Join Date: Dec 2008 Posts: 436 Pie Slices: 1 Given Pie 0 Times in 0 Posts Rep Power: 2	Saintsreport is pretty bad. their are a lot of delusional fans that feel as though they deserve to play every game at home "in the dome". I wish I had a quarter for every time I read the phrase "in the dome" when those tools are discussing a loss. Most of them don't realize football was invented in the elements to be played in the elements. There's a lot of butt hurt Bears haters over there too which makes it pretty funny. Entire threads dedicated to the hatred of a team that doesn't even play in their division. __________________ The Colts suck!

06-19-2009, 10:27 PM	#19
Skew Senior, SENIOR Member Join Date: Nov 2008 Age: 46 Posts: 4,004 Pie Slices: 2 Given Pie 3 Times in 2 Posts Rep Power: 11	I had to think about it for a while. And since I'm a mod here, I will give my opinion without including the Huddle compared to the other three boards to avoid any bias. I will give each board a grade of 1 -3 based on several factors, with 1 being the worst and 3 being the best. In each category, one team has to get a 1 vote, one team has to get a 2 vote, and one team has to get a 3 vote. Let's see how each does with the following categories for the Pewter Report board, Atlanta Falcons Message Board, and the Saints Board (pick one). So the highest score is the best. Shall we? Categories are: Professionalism of board Intellegence of posters Intellegence of mods/admins Posting of new NFL news How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against the norm. How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a player who has committed a crime. How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a mod/admin. How quickly a rival fan will be gang banged by other board members for having a different thought from the regular board members. "SHALL WE PLAY A GAME?" Professionalism of board Falcons 1 Saints 2 Bucs 3 Intellegence of posters Falcons 1 Saints 2 Bucs 3 Intellegence of mods/admins Falcons 1 Bucs 2 Saints 3 Posting of new NFL news Saints 1 Falcons 2 Bucs 3 How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against the norm. Bucs 1 Falcons 2 Saints 3 How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a player who has committed a crime. Falcons 1 Bucs 2 Saints 3 How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a mod/admin. Bucs 1 Falcons 2 Saints 3 How quickly a rival fan will be gang banged by other board members for having a different thought from the regular board members. Bucs 1 Saints 2 Falcons 3 Bonus points: Mods/Admins I've met from other boards who have made a positive influence on me can earn extra points. (Remember, this is my personal opinion, and by no means represents the official opinion of the Carolina Huddle). And the the final score is: Bucs: 16 Saints: 19 Falcons: 13 Bonusus points: I've met the mods for the Falcons board and they are just as much of idiots as their posters are, so that's -5 points. I'm surprised they scored that high. I was surprised that the Saints came out on top but I think that most people don't expect too many intellegent Saints fans to throw a curve in the grading. I would have thought the bucs would have come out on top. Anyway, try it yourself, exempting your team an see how it turns out. Skew __________________ Manana

06-19-2009, 10:35 PM	#20
Falcons1stPanthers2nd Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 1,582 Pie Slices: 0 Given Pie 0 Times in 0 Posts Rep Power: 5	Professionalism of board Panthers 1 Saints 2 Bucs 3 Intelligence of posters Saints 1 Panthers 2 Bucs 3 Intellegence of mods/admins Bucs 1 Panthers 2 Saints 3 Posting of new NFL news Saints 1 Bucs 2 Panthers 3 How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against the norm. Bucs 1 Saints 2 Panthers 3 How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a player who has committed a crime. Bucs 1 Saints 2 Panthers 3 How quickly a rival fan will be banned for speaking out against a mod/admin. Bucs 1 Saints 2 Panthers 3 How quickly a rival fan will be gang banged by other board members for having a different thought from the regular board members. Panthers 1 Bucs 2 Saints 3 Panthers-18 Saints-16 Bucs-14 I'd switch the Saints and Bucs but yeah. __________________ RIP to all who died at Pearl Harbor. You shall not be forgotten. RIP Great Uncle Herbert.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode