Jump to content



- - - - -

Scout On Dontari Poe: He Didn’t Do Anything

Apr 01 2012 11:33 AM jtnc Carolina Panthers

Posted Image

The excitement from Dontari Poe’s phenomenal Scouting Combine performance is starting to fade in the eyes of many league observers, who are turning their attention back to Poe’s tape — and not liking what they’re seeing.
Poe, the Memphis defensive tackle who took the Combine by storm by running a 4.87-second 40-yard dash at 346 pounds and bench-pressing 225 pounds 44 times, does not impress many of those who have watched him play.
He’ll be overdrafted,” one personnel man told the Times of Trenton. “He did all of that at the Combine, so some team will take him way higher than he should go. I mean watch him play, just watch. He didn’t do anything. And he wasn’t playing at a very high level, either. All I know is he had one sack last year and it came against Austin Peay. You probably didn’t even know Austin Peay had a football team.”
When Poe announced in December that he was entering the NFL draft, he said he’d been told he projected as a second-rounder who could move into the first round with a good Combine. Poe didn’t have a good Combine — he had a great Combine — and he started being discussed as a Top 5 pick.
So those who watched him bench press and run 40 yards in a straight line are more impressed than those who watched him play football. That’s not a good sign.



Do not want. If we HAVE to take a DT then take a Jerel Worthy or Brandon Thompson in the 2nd.
http://profootballta...nt-do-anything/

Απάντηση

59 Comments

:: before


Nothing new here for me. Despite his great combine, I was never impressed by Poe.
I wouldn't be surprised if they don't even have him come in for an interview....

He isn't a top draft pick. He is the type guy Carolina would draft in the 2nd to continue their horrible track record.

Rather have Brandon thompson over him. Better football player.....and will be drafted where he should go....2nd round
Yeah, I was definitely on the Poewagon after the combine, but I've been less and less into him as the days go by.
Though I'll be the first to admit that reading mock drafts is stupid and that they're all "educated" crapshoots that are wildly inaccurate and biased towards an "author's" opinion instead of based on 32 different opinions and team personalities... I love reading mock drafts on-line to tithe me over until draft day.

I'm so upset at the number of mocks that have us picking Poe at 9. Give me some variety, please! Poe at 9 would be a monumental mistake. And before any Poe supporters out there use the non-argument about Cam last year and the gamble associated with picking him, they are on two totally different levels when it comes to game tape and individual success leading to team success.

Just say no to Poe.
If you can't produce in C-USA, how the hell are you going to produce in the NFL?
Yeah, at least Cam did his thing with a less than dominant Auburn team that went undefeated and won a national title out of the SEC.
Just like with Cam early on, I was basically the only one that didn't want Poe even after the combine. I'm right yet again. Bow before me. Poe is another Bruce Campbell...workout warrior who is lazy on the field and eventually gets traded for 4th string running backs.

Yeah, I was definitely on the Poewagon after the combine, but I've been less and less into him as the days go by.


Same here. I'm very much on the Dre Kirkpatrick in the first and Thompson/Worthy in the second wagon now.
On NFL network, the lumped Coples and Poe together, neither getting a top 10 grade.
I wish we could just fuging trade down.
Coples is the guy i want if we go defense. Castro if we go offense. Assuming Claiborne and Blackmon are gone.
Work out warrior, I'm not sure who I want at 9 but I'd rather not have Poe.
If your going to draft on combine draft Brockers. He has a whole lot more upside and thats what scouts are seeing.
I'm not convinced we need a defensive tackle in the first round, or even the second.
Photo
Herbert The Love Bug
Apr 01 2012 12:57 PM
Yeah and Cam couldn't throw a football and in no way should have been the #1 overall pick. "If anyone you should take Blaine Gabbert" Scouts have proven to be geniuses over the years.


Also you need to remember, he hasn't played football that long. He was in band then the football asked him to try football. He is raw and has some work to do, but with NFL coaching and battling NFL olinemen everyday in practce, he has all the tools to be an awesome defensive tackle. I'm not saying to draft him though. I don't really know who I want and don't really care.
Photo
Herbert The Love Bug
Apr 01 2012 12:59 PM

Coples is the guy i want if we go defense. Castro if we go offense. Assuming Claiborne and Blackmon are gone.


I hope we don't draft coples. He has great size but poor, motor, stamina, work ethic, annoying arms. I watched every Carolina game and he was hardly ever doing anything. He will be a bust

Yeah and Cam couldn't throw a football and in no way should have been the #1 overall pick. "If anyone you should take Blaine Gabbert" Scouts have proven to be geniuses over the years.

If you're going to ridicule every person who has gotten a prospect wrong, you might as well just stop paying attention to the draft. It's all about probabilities, not absolutes. Amazing that people can't grasp this.

I hope we don't draft coples. He has great size but poor, motor, stamina, work ethic, annoying arms. I watched every Carolina game and he was hardly ever doing anything. He will be a bust


Many scouts have said Poe has a HORRIBLE motor.
I thought this was a widely known fact... He hasn't done SQUAT!
Lol @ people trying to predict the future.
Ingram or Kuechly if they go defense in the first round. Otherwise DeCastro or Reiff for the OL. They can still pick up a quality DT in the 2nd round.
Bruce Campbell.

Lol @ people trying to predict the future.


Nostradamus would like a word with you.
Every year there is a combine warrior that shoots up the draft boards. First round athlete, 2nd-3rd round football player. If we take him I'll be extremely disappointed.

Then again, I said the exact same thing about Cammy Cam. So lulz. Luckily, Hurney is literally perfect in the first round so I trust him to make the best pick.
I think poe is going to make alot of people on this board regret there words. Once again the tools are there. If u put in the effort this kid is a freak.