So here's my issue, the team was looking for a CMC clone and drafted a power RB. Was he a reach based on what was left? Scarlett has the power to move a pile, but if you look closely, he's very tight-hipped. He may have made some second and third string Bills look average, but can he do that against a starting defense? Instead of getting a CMC clone, we got a CAP clone. Holyfield is in that same mold too. The only RB that's even close to a CMC-type is Bonnofon and he's raw...a college QB and WR if memory serves me correctly.
Just kidding, it was actually the usual kind of person who does that stuff: