Correct. You can't take that context out of the equation.
The most recent evaluations that we have on Newton would fall under the category of "good, but limited". He performed well through the first eight games last year but it was still pretty obvious that something was wrong. This preseason, it didn't even get that far. Now there's concern about him possibly being fragile.
Yeah, I know. "He's Superman". Except he isn't.
He may be an athletic freak, but athletic freaks are still human.