Billy Goat

You're 0-5, 21-14 down and you've got 3 timeouts and 4th and 1 near the red zone with 30 seconds of the half left. You should never in any circumstance be settling for a FG there.

They looked better against Seattle because Reich altered the playbook per Dalton's request. Reich confirmed that in one of his press conferences. It seems a bit harsh to criticise Young for our limited playcalling in games he has started if it's by design.

Why on earth should they do that? The season is a write-off. We need to use the remaining games to give Young as many reps as possible. The whole sitting him to shadow a vet ship sailed long ago.

Ordinarily I'd say it's too early for a coach only 5 games into his tenure to get the boot, but considering he was hired as an offensive guru and considering how turgid and ill-disciplined this offense is, Reich doesn't really have a leg to stand on. He should be gone.

Looking back on it, the comments from Tepper about not needing elite receiver's are outrageous. The way he throws the ball, the way he’s a point guard, how you can use the different players on the field, how you might not have to have as many elite receivers because he’s the point guard, right? So he distributes the ball to people with routes. So we can save some money there, we can save money in other places and put that money on the defensive side of the ball. Young never stood a chance with these guys thinking you can give him some JAG receivers and put points on the board.

The only way I could see this happening is by getting draft capital for Burns, but trading Burns would signal rebuild and trading for a WR1 signals the opposite. So yeah, dumb decisions all around if it happens.

The version of Lafell Cam was throwing to in his rookie year would be the best receiver on this team. It's probably a toss of a coin deciding who's the better TE option with Shockey and Hurst. The offensive line that year was ranked 9th overall by PFF. You can't even compare what the two are working with.

Has to be traded at this point. He's not worth the money he'll demand and the team needs as many picks as possible. If they could get a 1st and a mid rounder for him they should do it without a second thought.

Let's not forget the first half. TMJ makes a catch on the Vikings 41, 28 seconds on the clock with two timeouts and he lets the clock run down and we get the play off with 12 seconds remaining. We come away with 3 points but there was an opportunity to be in a position to have a shot or two at the end zone. It's just really bad the whole game.

The TD to Chark last week was the one big play the offense has had in 4 games and that was credited to Thomas and Parks Frazier. Reich basically said Dalton asked to air it out a bit more against Seattle as well, so the way I see it Reich is intentionally calling these ultra safe, short yard plays. He's terrible.

I'm not convinced by Young but I'm reluctant to call him a bust with the way the playcalling has been. The question is are these calls part of the game plan or are they catered around the QBs limitations? Every game Young has played in the announcers have constantly pointed out that they need to open up the field and go long and it never happens. Is that on Reich or on Young?

Reich is trash. Awful game management.

This playcalling.....Definitely the sort of stuff to keep the stadium empty for the rest of the year.

Becoming a bit of a chore to watch us throw screens and 5 yard passes all game. Reich's playcalling leaves a lot to be desired.

That's bullshit.

He's playing like a rookie on a bad offense with a coach that won't let him throw further than 15yds.

I'd rather point out the obvious than wildly speculate that someone wishing death on the internet is a Panther's player, with coincidence being the main proof for accusation.

I mean that could quite literally be anyone who follows the Panthers and has access to the internet.

If he has surgery he's probably going to be out for 4 months, so basically season ending. Ordinarily you'd say bring in a body but if they're planning on doing nothing this season then they might as well not bother.

A bit ridiculous to compare his first game to Cam's. Smith, LaFell, Olsen and Shockey probably get more seperation against the Atlanta D if they suited up this past Sunday, nevermind what they were doing back in 2011.

Have to echo what others have said. It's a team coming off a 7-10 record which could've easily been 9-8 with how close the losses were at the falcons and giants. Granted rookie QBs struggle but not many come into a team with a solid foundation. This team should absolutely be in with a shot at making the play-offs.

I don't understand the logic in criticising a great pass into a tight window because it may have lead to a DB making a tackle after the catch. Isn't that football? It feels like a running theme in the last few years reading people complain about passes because a big hit lands on the catcher directly after. It's a contact sport.

I'd say 1. Thielen, 2. Chark, 3. Mingo/Marshall, 4. Mingo/Marshall, 5. Shenault Mingo and Marshall likely fight it out for that 3rd spot in camp.

Seen some scout reports that say he could be used as a nickel, so they might have picked him with that in mind.