Oh I agree. QBR and PR are just indicators. I would never make QB decisions just on either of them and I can see where you got that from my post.
We should cut him if the coaches determine his play was bad. If your play is bad, it is often reflected in the indicators.
Some point to Tannehill as an example of a jump like that. He was older, had better success earlier in his career before Gase, and was battling injuries, so some argue its not a fair comparison.
We really don't know what we have. You see flashes of a really good QB, there was just so much crap, it's hard to say.
We'll find out.
I don’t think our staff is going to look at QBR. You can have a great QBR and still lose games. Teddy ranking 17 is middle if the pack, yet he was 0-8 in game winning drives. If Darnold is 19, but makes the throws needed to win games that would be a nice upgrade. If he becomes the leader of the offense and gets some wins due to his play, I think we roll with him again.