All Time Panther Roster

[Carl Spackler]

19 minutes ago, MasterAwesome said:

You know you've had a pretty crazy resume with linebackers when you can't even fit Jon Beason into your list.

I'd only carry one FB and add Beason.

[Mage]

9 hours ago, Carl Spackler said:

Ken Lucas or even Munnerlyn over Horn right now 

Richard Marshall deserves consideration.  I know he was inconsistent here, but what Panthers CB hasn't been?  His 2009 season was great IIRC.  Certainly better than any season Munnerlyn had.

Ken Lucas was SO bad in 2008 that I think it bars him from any consideration in an "all-time" list.  Ken Lucas in the second half of that season to the playoffs might be the worst corner play in Panthers history and that is saying a lot.  

[Carl Spackler]

2 minutes ago, Mage said:

Richard Marshall deserves consideration.  I know he was inconsistent here, but what Panthers CB hasn't been?  His 2009 season was great IIRC.  Certainly better than any season Munnerlyn had.

Ken Lucas was SO bad in 2008 that I think it bars him from any consideration in an "all-time" list.  Ken Lucas in the second half of that season to the playoffs might be the worst corner play in Panthers history and that is saying a lot.  

Nah man, there's definitely been worse than that. Not that it was good, but Jesus Christ, Keith Taylor last year was not even USFL-tier in that timeframe. I think Jackson deserved it above any of them and clarified it right after. 

Congrats on the Derby

[Cullenator]

I think Id have to put Jenkins above Short.  It may be time messing with my old brain but I remember games that he regularly seemed to be on the other side of the ball before the QB knew he had it.

 

Dude was a monster.

[thefuzz]

Moton deserves to be on the list, and Beason should find a home there as well...otherwise, pretty damn good.

Safety makes me want to throw something.

[CRA]

Trai Turner is getting in at G for me.

I'm going Lathon at OLB over Spoon

I'd also put Beason over Morgan. But I get it either way that goes. 

I can't put Horn on that list either.  He hasn't even logged a full season worth of games yet.  

Godfrey shouldn't be the #2 all time Safety.   We ain't got much there but I just couldn't do that. 

[jfra78]

20 minutes ago, CRA said:

Trai Turner is getting in at G for me.

I'm going Lathon at OLB over Spoon

I'd also put Beason over Morgan. But I get it either way that goes. 

I can't put Horn on that list either.  He hasn't even logged a full season worth of games yet.  

Godfrey shouldn't be the #2 all time Safety.   We ain't got much there but I just couldn't do that. 

The reason I put Spoon over Lathon was I remember Lathon being mediocre when Greene left and I really liked Witherspoon

This list is super subjective and I admit I had a hard time remembering some players.  It's easy until you start getting to 3rd and 4th player at a position

[Thorrez]

Griffith was the best fb in league in the era fbs mattered, I'm surprised no one jumped on that yet.

Or I guess I need to realize how old I am...

[CRA]

OP wisely left off who is coaching that team.  That's where the real drama is lol. 

[MHS831]

6 hours ago, Dingo_ate_Babies said:

We should do an All-time list, but with a twist. You may include guys who were 1-year players, but had great careers elsewhere or 1-hit wonders. Here's mine:

QB: Newton, Delhomme, Beurlein, Collins

WR: Smitty, Muhammad, Keyshawn, Jeffers

TE: Olsen, Shockey, Walls

OL: Gross, Khalil, Wharton, Wahle, 

RB: CMC, Stewart, Williams, Stephen Davis

FB: Hoover, Tolbert

 

DL: Peppers, Rucker, Charles Johnson, Reggie White, Jenkins, Hardy

LB: Luke, TD, Kevin Greene, Mills, Lathon

CB: Gamble, Norman, Tillman, Bradberry, Eric Davis, Lucas

S: Minter, Coleman, 

K: Casey

P: Hekker

 

 

MIght consider OG Evan Mathis on this

[jfra78]

5 minutes ago, CRA said:

OP wisely left off who is coaching that team.  That's where the real drama is lol. 

I'll let the Huddle coach

[KatsAzz]

10 hours ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Deon Grant is definitely the best FS we've ever had, sad as that is. He was decent but by no means great. We've just never put much value in the position generally fielding two SS types.

I'm finding a spot on that roster somewhere for Beason. Moton has to be there too. Hopefully after another year or too Ickey will be too. It's not like we have an illustrious history at OT.

 

 I agree with you that both Beason and Moton deserve to be there too.

[OneBadCat]

Are we going on prestige or just ability on the field? 

 

QB- Cam Newton, Jake Delhomme

RB- CMC, Deangelo Williams, Jonathan Stewart

FB- Brad Hoover

WR- Smith, Muhammad, DJ Moore, Ted Ginn

TE- Olsen, Walls

LT-Gross

LG-Wharton

C- Kalil

RG- Trai Turner

RT- Moton (Really temping to put Otah here, but Moton is so well rounded)

 

4-3

RE- Julius Peppers

DT- Kris Jenkins

NT- Star

LE- Greg Hardy

 

ROLB- Thomas Davis

MLB- Luke Keuchly

LOLB-Will Witherspoon

 

3-4

DE- D. Brown

NT- Jenkins

DE- Short, Star

 

EDGE/LB- Julius Peppers, Kevin Greene, Brian Burns

MLB/ILB- Luke Keuchly, Dan Morgan, Thomas Davis

 

SS- Mike Minter, Thomas Davis (I'd rotate him here in the 3-4)

FS- Deon Grant

 

CB 1- Chris Gamble

CB-2 Josh Norman

CB 3-Jayce Horn (Out of position but has the athleticism to play the nickel)

 

K- Kasay

P- Sauerbrun

 

KR- Micheal Bates

PR- Steve Smith

Edited May 10, 2023 by OneBadCat