If you could bring back 4 former players in their prime who would it be

[mc52beast 5,802]

Question was asked on WFNZ this morning, thought it would make interesting discussion . Here’s my three;

1)Steve Smith: a no-brainer. Just throw it his way and he’ll catch it

2)Kevin Greene: would be an absolute beast in Ron’s 3-4. Double digit sacks easily.

3)Ryan Kalil: Paradis has been horrible so far. Would instantly upgrade the o-line.

4)Cam Newton: Cam in his prime takes this team on a deep playoff run, no doubt

 

Edited October 17, 2019 by mc52beast

[Riverboat Ron 4,577]

1) Reggie White

2) Julius Peppers

3) Kevin Greene

4) Steve Smith

 

You wouldn't even need the last one because the opposing QB would be dead after facing that trio.

 

Edited October 17, 2019 by Riverboat Ron

[toldozer 2,913]

Steve smith

Reggie white

Peppers 

Josh norman

[Prowler2019 14]

Steve Smith

Julius Peppers

Ryan Kalil

Kris Jenkins

[BrianS 1,497]

Steve Smith, Julius Peppers, Greg Olsen, Chris Gamble

 

[Dex 16,885]

Julius Peppers, Steve Smith, Reggie White and Chris Gamble.

[DeAngelo Beason 605]

1 - Smitty

2 - Pep

3 - Kevin Greene

4 - Jordan Gross

You put those four, in their primes, on this team right now, and we would win a few superbowls in a row.

[kungfoodude 3,833]

1. Steve Smith

2. Julius Peppers

3. Jordan Gross

4. Ryan Kalil

[WUnderhill 824]

Did their prime have to be with the Panthers? If not, Reggie White is about as easy of a choice as you can get. Evan Mathis in his prime could also really help this team. Also interesting to imagine what Thomas Davis in his prime with no knee injury would have been like. We got a glimpse before the first injury. He would have been an absolute monster.

Depending on the answer to the first question:

1. Reggie White or Julius Peppers

2. Steve Smith

3. Cam

4. Evan Mathis or Ryan Kalil or ... John Kasay

Honestly we’d win the Super Bowl with just prime Cam and Steve provided this oline keeps playing competently.

[Moo Daeng 3,007]

Smith

Newton

Gross

Eric Davis

I could answer this many valid ways

 

[ncfan 9,503]

Conisdering how our defense has been rushing the passer

 

1. Smitty- shouldnt even be in question 

2. Ryan Kalil- dude was a Beast in his prime and Paradis has struggled

3. Gross- Daley has looked good, in a small sample.  But Gross was a true franchise LT.  Could maybe put Daley at RT and Moton at LG at that point

4. Cam if we're talking healthy in their prime.  2015 Cam was a monster.  

[332nd 2,504]

4. Cam Newton.

3. Steve Smith.

2. Steve Smith.

1. Steve Smith.

If we're going to speculate on magic time travel, I'm going all out.

[1of10Charnatives 1,839]

What makes this an interesting discussion is not just who's great from the past, but who fills holes we have now. I could say Sam Mills, but Luke's got that MLB thing pretty well taken care of. 

1. Smitty no brainer as others have said.

2. Peppers in his prime also a no brainer.

3. Gonna go with Kalil over Gross just based on the fact center looks much weaker atm than LT.

4. Tempted to pull a name out no one has brought up: Michael Bates. However the changes to kickoffs have made returning skills less needed, so can't justify it just on his value as a gunner. I think the consensus of Reggie White is kind of hard to argue with.

[1of10Charnatives 1,839]

3 minutes ago, 332nd said:

4. Cam Newton.

3. Steve Smith.

2. Steve Smith.

1. Steve Smith.

If we're going to speculate on magic time travel, I'm going all out.

I weep for the DC staying up at night trying to figure out how to cover 3 smittys on the field at the same time. Talk about unmanageable.

[SmittysLawnGuy 390]

Legadu,  Nakamura, Pickles, M. Kahlil.

Tank for Tua!