Cdparr7

1 hour ago, Mother Grabber said:

this dude has to be connected to PJ in some way. he can’t just be a kid in his room pounding the keyboard this hard over a mid level backup

That’s what I’m saying. 

9 minutes ago, OldhamA said:

Randy Fasani has a 0.0 QB rating in an NFL game for us.

He's not even the worst QB to ever put on a uniform for the Panthers as he at least made it to the regular season. 

Oh yes Fasani. The Stanford guy.

6 minutes ago, SBBlue said:

I can see where it can seem weird.  I honestly wouldn't have given Darnold another look had we not traded for him.  I thought wtf are they doing?  When we had Darnold, and Fields was there at 8 I thought for sure we'd take Fields.  Darnold was insurance in case no good QB's fell.  Nope, they rode with Darnold.  So then after it was official we're rolling this guy, I thought I'd dig into it a little bit.  I started with highlights, but then watched some games.  The guy has talent, and most people agree on that.  There were flashes in most games.

So I figured I'd do a look into just how bad the jets were, outside the QB.  That's when I realized that Fit and Rhule were on to something.  When you have one of the worst o-lines in the league, with one of the highest pressure %, shortest unpressured pocket time, receivers with the dropsies who can't get separation, franchise-record-low run game, no QB coach, and literally have trouble snapping the ball, it became apparent that Darnold was carrying too much with that team.  In three years he missed several games for injury and illness.  They didn't win ONE game he missed.  Not one.  That's when I joined the "give Darnold a chance" club.

Some people aren't going to switch until we're winning.  That's fine.  

Yeah but PJ would have blocked for himself and threw it to himself on a playbook he wrote the night before so we better start him, especially after the MVP like performance Sunday. 

1 hour ago, amcoolio said:

Jimmy Clausen can at least throw a touchdown. I would bet the under on 0.5 touchdowns if you gave Grier 10 straight offensive drives. Clausen also had a 107.6 rating in a win once. Grier undoubtedly would go 0-16. He is that bad.

Clausen started 12 games roughly?

Grier started 2 when Fewell was HC behind an OL way worse than 2010? 
 

He didn’t play last season? It’s reaching to make that assumption.

9 minutes ago, glenwo2 said:

I'd rather have Minshew backing up Sam than PJ but that's just me. 

Now there is some common sense this thread was lacking.

5 minutes ago, CPsinceDay1 said:

So if PJ clearly performing better in practice, in game's, you really think they continue to stick with Darnold if he's not showing any improvement. Maybe Darnold hasn't really picked up the playbook, Cam was limited in NE because of the new playbook terminology. Is Darnold having a hard time adjusting??? 

You pick up the 5th option, as many have said the deadline was around the corner...but you can fool some people some of the time, but not all the people all the time...that locker room is watching 

PJ, please just show us on Saturday and stop posting in The Huddle!

32 minutes ago, CPsinceDay1 said:

https://www.google.com/amp/s/touchdownwire.usatoday.com/lists/2021-nfl-preseason-p-j-walker-rhamondre-stevenson/amp/

PJ making National Headlines....

 

I wanted Minshew over Darnold. 
 

Don’t think it will happen, will put too much pressure on Sam.

Not sure it’s time to boot him out but I am surprised that there isn’t legitimate competition in camp with him.

By legitimate I mean a vet and not somebody  Undrafted out of the university of North-Central Idaho Methodist who opted out last year.

4 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Our backup quarterback situation is a worldwide emergency?

I mean I grant it's bad, but...

These people were probably on the Armanti Edwards bandwagon too.

2 minutes ago, CRA said:

only 1 stat matters.  Ws. 

Remember when Matt Moore was 6-2 as a starter going into the 2010 season? 
 

that went well.

4 minutes ago, Tinamedina said:

 

im aware. i just know its based on emotion and status quo vs logic. 

1 TD-5INTS last season.

Maybe he can play Safety.

They should put PJ at LT since he solved all of our problems according to the Huddle.

1 minute ago, CPsinceDay1 said:

Beuerlein haha, Weinke, there was false hope there, Moore, your wanted it but the team was no where near as talented, K.Allen was just fool's gold bc some folks hated Cam.

I would love to hear Delhomme's point of view on PJ, I'm quite sure, many of us would be surprise at his take

His point of view would likely be to sign 3 new QBs because they are all horrible.

“Since the XFL and Temple”. Like 3 years ago. I’ve been a fan since 95 and I’ve seen the “back up QB is better” for 26 years now and it was only true once (Delhomme).

I remember when Beuerlein was the answer, when Weinke was the answer, when Basanez/Pike was the answer, when Moore was the answer, and when Kyle Allen was the answer. 
 

PJ Walker is not even close to being the answer. He’s not better than Darnold or half of the folks I named above.

Just now, Tinamedina said:

naw he just has his own fans base that goes back to the XFL and some people remember him from Temple.

Well somebody needs to inform y’all he’s garbage.

PJ had a lot of accounts these days.

1 hour ago, Panthers8969 said:

The coaches couldn’t bench their 63m dollar man lol. Watch the lions game again. The tempo of the offense was far superior to that of any led by teddy 

Kyle Allen was better than PJ.

3 hours ago, Jmac said:

How long a leash will they give S.D if he is struggling? Half a season? The entire season? P.J is the only option if they have to look elsewhere. Grier is not an option.

Will the coach pull the plug if the starter isn't working out?

Everyone is forgetting he went 10/21 and threw a touchdown on accident.

He had 1 TD and 2 INTs in his start. And threw 3 INTs against the Saints.

He is butt.

See who can get the most right.

I say:

Ivey, Hyman, Clark, Donnerson, Julius

22 hours ago, amcoolio said:

Is there a Panthers QB in our history that is worse than him? I don't think so

 

I'd rather they bring in someone that can throw the ball downfield and be aggressive even if they aren't accurate. Or someone that can run. Grier solves no purpose. He doesn't have an NFL skill and he's slower than molasses.

Let me introduce to you *Pickles*

1 minute ago, Ricky Spanish said:

yeah that was soft. 

dude earned the right to show some fire, he ran through like 8 dudes. 

I’m for relaxing the taunting penalties. But also need to relax the helmet/helmet and roughing the passer penalties. 
 

Reset everything to the early 2000s minus the tuck rule.

A co-worker of mine that was transferred to a different office called me over the weekend. He had his first and second dose about a month ago and tested positive.

1 minute ago, CPsinceDay1 said:

I'm not hating on Will, I just dislike the way people try to discredit PJ by trying to somehow say Will pulled the wrong straw....

What translates in practice carries over to the game, the proof is in the pudding.

Basically Darnold shouldn't have ne more problems with the 1s then PJ had with the 2s...

Here's the main difference....Will : I just ran what was called...

PJ: I dunno I was just having fun, I heard something on the headset, coach was yelling on the sidelines but I just KNEW I had to make a play, by getting it to my playmakers...

Alright so if the stats were reversed today you wouldn’t be trying to justify that PJ was taking snaps from a DT and playing with DIII athletes?

Honestly they are both garbage and we should have a true QB2. I want them both to be successful but we have a 3rd round pick in Grier and 3 years on the roster. 
 

If it comes to the two of them, I would rather Will be the guy since we have so much invested. But only if he is truly more talented, and we will only see that with them in same circumstances.

He and Haynes played most of the 1st half with the 2s. The second half was mostly Herron, Donnerson, and Miller at DE.

Morgan Fox is probably the started but I think YGM is safe at second string.