Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Kurb

DC Candidates Thread.

190 posts in this topic

Deep enough?

Possibly, but only if he goes to a system working underneath a defensive minded head coach.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dave McGinnis is a longtime favorite of mine. he ran great defenses as the DC and head coach of the Cardinals and has been working on the staff of defensive mind Jeff Fisher since being let go from Arizona. Add in that he and Fox are acquainted from their days coaching against each other in the old NFC East.

"Acquainted" doesn't quite cover Fox and Herman Edwards though. They're old buddies and you'd have to believe Fox would want Herm here if, as expected, the Chiefs let him go. Herm's never been a DC, but he was a defensive coach and like Fox is a "player's coach". Plus, he's been a head coach, so DC should actually be a little less demanding.

Then there's Sean McDermott. No connection to Fox that I know of, but he's the "hot young name" out there now and comes from Jim Johnson's school of aggressive D in Philly.

Deep enough?

The only downside to McDermott is that if he was to come here and change Carolina's D into a solid defense, it would only increase his chances of becoming a head coach for another team next year

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Damn, I was way off on the name lol

I was wondering who you were talking about. lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

10.jpg

One of the brightest, young defensive minds in the league, Sean McDermott enters his 10th season in Philadelphia. McDermott was named secondary coach on January 28, 2008, after a successful one-year stint as linebackers coach last season.

"I don't think there are a lot of secondary coaches that are as good as Sean McDermott," Eagles head coach Andy Reid said. "He was a phenomenal linebackers coach and, really, his versatility I just think is second to none."

sean.jpg?t=1232303104

Up and comer looks exactly like what the Panthers need as a Defensive Coordinator. Great blood lines under Andy Reid and Jim Johnson.

Let's got get 'em.

http://www.carolinahuddle.com/forum/carolina-panthers/6313-sean-mcdermott-dc-please.html#post1906004

.

.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And now, the downsides...

My fear with McDermott is that he'd have Johnson's aggressiveness without Johnson's experience. That could be an issue. Add in that he might have an entirely new young staff below him, though hopefully the team would pick up someone with some experience to help the transition.

Edwards? The obvious issue is that he's never held a DC spot, but he's been a step below and a step above. Add in that he's considered a good motivator. The friendship with Fox? Double edged sword, as anyone who has worked with a friend can tell you.

The guy with the fewest question marks to me is McGinnis. As a DC, he ran defenses that were aggressive, but also balanced. Still, outside of their old NFC East acquaintance, there's no definite indication that he'd be on Fox's radar.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only downside to McDermott is that if he was to come here and change Carolina's D into a solid defense, it would only increase his chances of becoming a head coach for another team next year

Thought of that. An even bigger risk given the league's penchant for hiring youngsters these days.

Edwards isn't as likely to get another shot as a head coach since he did so poorly in his previous opportunities.

McGinnis, likewise, has been there and hasn't been on anyone's head coaching radar for a while.

McDermott would be the hot guy, but if you're looking for someone more likely to be long term, Edwards and McGinnis are the best fits.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd prefer Herm Edwards. The long friendship between him and Fox would make him gel very well here I believe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ron Rivera

:lol:

I heard he was in town tomorrow.:angelsad2:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites