CRA

Last checkdown QB we signed had a record of 22-12 when we got him.

I think SF might need Jimmy G. I’m not sure everyone in SF sees eye to eye

Fine w/ that. I just don't want to add these caliber QBs to the mix. I also don't want Matt Corral to be the week 1 starter. I don't think there will be nor do I want a legit open competition. But I want him to play to get an idea of what he might have. Because I think after this season we will want to know to make our next play/move. I do think the fanbase/stadium will allow us to see Corral at some point if it is just Sam/PJ on the roster. I think we just repeat last year and eventually Corral just has to get out there. Hopefully we won't see it until mideseason.

you said there was no comparison. I responded to that narrative. The comparison is they are both checkdown QBs. Teddy and Jimmy G. And they do compare statistically too. I responded to that. They have very high and similar career completion percentages because of all the checking down. whatever the goal of the article is doesn't matter lol. Unless you think he is falsely being portrayed as a checkdown QB by the author. That was just the first one that popped up on a google search because it is a long discussed issue of Jimmy's.

I'm saying you are one of the key cogs of what you are complaining about. You spend most of your time here being upset because people think Matt Rhule sucks.

I mean if you are into hot italian guys I can at least accept that as an arguement.

I think I read the post wrong. You said make it past 7 games. I read that as wins intitially. That's where my mind got 8. You meant CMC. But yeah, I'd take the over if forced with 6. I can't get much higher.

Even San Francisco media is tired of Checkdown Jimmy G leading the 49ers (msn.com) yeah, there is. They are both checkdown QBs that can't and don't make the throws downfield you need from a QB. That comparison has been here since Jimmy's name was very first brought up awhile back. * It's why they have almost identical career completion %.

I'd just rather get Matt Corral on the field by midseason. That seems more fruitful and has more purpose. I think adding these guys stops that from happening.

we had him. his name was Teddy. and Jimmy G would just be our #1 QB. QB discussion over.

If Matt Rhule gets his hands on Jimmy G no one here is seeing Matt Corral. New season, same Panthers. The brand is basically Groundhog Day.

Jimmy is a good dude. He cares

I mean, the Rhule and Tepper hate would probably go from an 8 to a soothing 4....if there weren't Rhule and Tepper fanboys running around every day claiming the Earth is flat. kind of like here. You once again, are complaining about people complaining about Matt Rhule. Which you do over and over. Often not in response to someone actually complaining about him. Of course you do that then too. Because someone can't just say Matt Rhule sucks and you let that slide as a reality. I mean the Qanon theorist comparable isn't people saying Rhule/Tepper suck. As you say. It's those that argue they don't suck and/or have a problem w/ it being pointed out. And they insist on making that known over and over again.

I have yet to see someone take a schedule and put the actual 8 wins out there though. It would then require the Panthers pulling some big upsets IMO after basically running the table on all the close ones.

Matt Rhule needs wins to stay employed.

and excuding somewhere like maybe Montana. Most of the maps where internet is lacking is prime college football real estate.

If already said if I had laid money I would take the over because I am calling for 6 wins. But that line is perfect at 5.5. Hard to figure out which side of it to go.

and Chuba can’t catch well. Foreman has 18 career catches over 4 years that’s not insurance for if CMC goes down. All it takes is one player getting hurt (CMC) and we are in a bad spot. And his history makes that an important issue.

Maybe you could supply a list of what we can and can’t talk about. so we shouldn’t talk about the roster and how we could improve in areas. Like this thread. can’t talk about our bad coaches and owner. what else?

Teddy largely was. He just refused to make the throws he needed to. O still has problems but Teddy not pulling the trigger on plays that existed was the primary problem that year on O. 2020 and 2021 IMO can't be lumped as the same messes/problems.

this ranking has a similar feel to the one where Carolina earned greatest uniforms of all time.

and frankly their WRs too. Unless you just want depth and roleplayers. No one has really panned out post Keyshawn and I always thought he was overrated.

I mean they all are dirtbags. Jimbo was just accused a couple years back of sorts of stuff. Hard to rise to the ranks of the most elite college programs and not be a seedy dirtbag. Except for Dabo. And if you disagree, Dabo and I will pray for your lost soul. You're welcome. Think it actually is easier for a decent man to be NFL coach than at a top tier college program.

the rule is often great players make bad coaches if you look at GOAT coaches that played....they normally weren't very good. If you look at GOAT players that coached...they normally sucked

QBs with weaker physical tools have gone to situations just as bad....and performed better. Sam is an athlete. Not a QB. Simple as that. Thinking you can make him one just isn't going to happen. Not when his physical tools would limit him to being a traditional pocket passer.