Why doesn't anyone include Steve Smith in their top 10 WR lists?

[RealisticPanther]

That's just not true brandon_87. The top 10 list is a lot more suspect than you'd think. names often mentioned, as I've pointed out: Tory Holt, Larry Fitzgerald, Marvin Harrison, Cris Carter.

I just don't believe personally any of them were better than smith as a player, even if they had better careers or stats.

Others besides me have pointed out many valid, logical reasons as to why we consider smith better than some of them and none of those reasons are unreasonable.

Its kind've like when people were saying lesean mccoy was better than Adrian peterson when McCoy had that one great season for the eagles. One was facing 8 in the box nearly every play, one wasn't. Smith was double covered practically his whole career, Larry Fitzgerald wasn't..and they still have practically identical numbers.

[E CaT PanTHer 2]

7 hours ago, LinvilleGorge said:

As much as I love Jake, if Smitty had the luxury of playing with a legit top QB he would've put up even bigger numbers. Ot pains me to admit it, but the biggest difference between Smitty and Antonio Brown is Jake cam Big Ben.

disagree. Jake had a tendency to feed his number 1 WR. I mean I think Muhsin Muhammed leading the league in TD's the year smitty went down says all you need to know. 

[BlueGopher]

I totally do. So underrated. He kind of reminds me of Fitzgerald. Clutch and way good. It's because he's small.