mcdougal

HUDDLER
  • Content count

    1,027
  • Joined

  • Last visited


Community Reputation

563 Good

About mcdougal

  • Rank
    LEGIT

Recent Profile Visitors


2,539 profile views

mcdougal's Activity

  1. mcdougal added a post in a topic For all of you that wish we were like the Colts...   

    The point is that the Colt's fan base do not see their front office go offense year after year and then EXPECT their defense to lead the way.
    We, on the other hand, see our front office year after year shift resources into the defense then EXPECT our offense to lead the way and complain about the offense when we fail to outright win games where the opponent scores into the 30s.
    See last year vs. Cinn.
    • 0
  2. mcdougal added a post in a topic We're a Funchess injury away from tonight, all season (or as long as DF is out) therefore ...   

    The disturbing part is that we are once again going into a season with a rookie WR as the No. 1. This time the rookie is a second round pick. Maybe next year we can really do big things and go in with an undrafted rookie as the No. 1.
    And this rookie hasn't even been healthy enough to play in the last two pre-season games so he will go in with zero live action with his QB.
    Finally (as was the case with Benjamin), for all we know, Funchess is a complete and utter bust. We are just assuming that he is better than what we have but who knows...he might be worse.
    • 0
  3. mcdougal added a post in a topic Very good game by Cam   

    It has got to be a play design thing. Doesn't matter who we have at WR, defenders are always in great position to make the tackle and rarely are WRs wide open. It looks like all we is line up and run routes with the goal of getting someone open. But in better passing offenses the thing I notice is that the OC will use other WRs to clear out or free up other WRs for easier catches and more run.
    But I also free it is a lack of talent on offense and Newton could do a better job of leading WRs/throwing in front of them so they can stay upright and run.
    But if this offense continues to be a "catch and down" offense, we will continue to struggle to score TDs and continue to be inconsistent. We should not be relying on Newton for every single yard in the passing game. OC/pass catchers need to step up and make plays.
    • 0
  4. mcdougal added a post in a topic Very good game by Cam   

    Can we talk about the lack of YAC this offense produces? One of the reasons this offense will be choppy at best is because everything in the passing game comes off the right arm of Newton.
    No wonder Newton doesn't throw short. If he does we'll be in a lot of 3rd and 7.
    • 2
  5. mcdougal added a post in a topic Preseason Game 3 Thread: Patriots vs Panthers 730 P.M. General thoughts, previews, etc in here   

    Once again. Zero YAC on that drive. Everything cannot come off the right arm of Newton.
    • 0
  6. mcdougal added a post in a topic Initial Diagnosis on Jordy Nelson is Torn ACL   

    I am not a doctor, but it seems as though that anytime an athlete goes down on a non-contact play, it's an ACL tear. 
    • 0
  7. mcdougal added a post in a topic Reggie Wayne to New England?   

    Let's bookmark this thread. When next month comes, and these very people start to bitch about our offense scoring only ten points against mediocre defenses, we know whose post to cite "the answer is on the roster" and "our offense/WRs are fine".  
    • 1
  8. mcdougal added a post in a topic Official Panthers - Dolphins GameDay Thread   

    That defense better be prepared to step up better than this. This team is built around them. Too much of our resources is tied up in that side of the field for them to allow two TD drives in 2 possessions.
    By the Dolphins.
    • 1
  9. mcdougal added a post in a topic Rosenthal: In reality, the Panthers have a roster full of No. 4 receivers   

    As I said before, it is not the "wrong" approach. Just the approach that IMO makes less sense given who are head coach and offensive coordinator are, and one I would not take. But the this approach can lead to a Superbowl.
    I personally do not feel that way about Gettleman and his approach to our offense. I feel as though Gettleman cares about our offense only to the extent that it doesn't drastically interfere with his ability to build an elite defense.
    I am not so sure about that "rebuilt the offense line in front of him..." assertion. And yes he has given Newton a fair deal, which means that Newton should be expected to elevate his level of play given that he is sucking up more of the cap/ resources. However, that doesn't mean that Newton should be subjected to mediocre talent either. As you know, there are many NFL teams that right now play their QBs handsomely and continue to field talented players in other positions on the offense. 
     
    And as I continue to say, what I want is for Panther fans to recognize that the Panthers didn't build a team in the image of the Packers or Falcons or Broncos or Colts. So come September we should not litter the Huddle with threads entitled: "Newton and the offense are bums, 17 points against the Falcons isn't going to cut it..."
     
    • 0
  10. mcdougal added a post in a topic Rosenthal: In reality, the Panthers have a roster full of No. 4 receivers   

    I am not sure I agree with that. Since Newton has been drafted, for example, the Panthers have drafted a defensive player (while the offense has never been what I would truly consider elite) in the first round 3/4 years.
    DG has had 3 draft opportunities. IMO, his biggest priority appears, to date, to be building an elite defense. The Jags, for example, have done more in the draft, IMO, to surround Brotles with talent in 2 seasons than the Panthers have for Newton in 5 seasons. 
    Again, the approach isn't the biggest problem. It is the approach coupled with our fans then expecting an elite offense is the concern. 
    • 1
  11. mcdougal added a post in a topic Rosenthal: In reality, the Panthers have a roster full of No. 4 receivers   

    Let me say this about the Colts' philosophy.The Colts' fans do not see the front office dump a disportionate amount on their resources on offense, and then expect their defense to lead the way or expect them to hold their opponents to single digits.
    The opposite is mostly true in Carolina. We witness a front office clearly trying to establish an elite defense and are willing to make certain sacrifices to the offense in order to achieve that goal. But then, Panthers fans go crazy when the offense (who was mediocre at best the prior year) goes out and scores 10 points against the Seahawks in week 5. 
    IMO, a team could win a championship in this manner. I personally would not put all my eggs in the defensive basket, but I am not paid millions to be a NFL GM.
    I have said this before, both the Colts and Panther's rebuild initially looked very similar: Defensive "genius" Head Coach, aging No. 1 WR, suspect defense, No. 1 overall pick. The Panthers went QB...so did the Colts a season later.
    That is where the similarities end. The Colts next draft pick after Luck, was his college roommate, a TE. The Panther's refused to even take a offensive skill player high until Newton's 4th year (and only after getting rid of his top 4 WRs).
    The Colts, on the other hand, hired Luck's college coordinator, drafted high offensive skills players, traded away high draft picks for offensive skill players, went out into free agency and got offensive skill players, and completely and totally built the team around Luck's skill set.
    The funny part is that Newton's rookie campaign established that you could build around him in the same manner...but only the Colts deemed it necessary to surround their No. 1 overall QB with whatever he needed (and then some)...The Panthers basically took the exact opposite approach. 
     
    Finally, I think that the Colts' approach makes far more sense. I never understood why the Jets, year after year, drafted defensive players, while having an absolute terrible offense, when they claimed that Rex Ryan was a defensive genius...Like if Rex is a genius why does he need to spend all the team's resources on that side of the ball...when his offense sucks?
    What the Bucs are attempting, IMO, is the correct approach. If you hire a defensive "wizard," you make him prove it. You go get a QB, a strong offensive coordinator, and try to surround that QB with everything he needs to excel. The "genius" defensive head coach should be able to do more with less...that is why he was hired in the first place.
    That is what the Colts, IMO, does with Chuck Pagano. Pagano doesn't have to build the No. 1 defense, but he should demonstrate that his defense is capable of getting key stops and at least capable of not giving up 30 every week.
    For whatever reason, the Panthers are intent on giving our "genius" head coach everything his scheme wants at the expense of our already mediocre to poor offense.
     
    • 3
  12. mcdougal added a post in a topic Rosenthal: In reality, the Panthers have a roster full of No. 4 receivers   

    I will probably get shot for this...but Chud wasn't bad. I would even say he was good (not the best, not great) coordinator...
    • 2
  13. mcdougal added a post in a topic Rosenthal: In reality, the Panthers have a roster full of No. 4 receivers   

    The sad thing is by the 3rd week of September, a number of Huddle posters will be screaming about Newton failing to put up 40 points and how we need to depend on our offense to lead the way.
    • 19
  14. mcdougal added a post in a topic Reality at WR - moving forward   

    Unfortunately, this is exactly what I am afraid of...our passing, IMO, already relies too much on complicated, down the field passing. 
    Now we are going to try to do it with a core that is best suited as 2s and 3s and 4s... 
    • 0
  15. mcdougal added a post in a topic Official Panthers - Bills GameDay Thread   

    Our offensive approach, once again, worries me.
    IMO, this offense is entirely too hard. Everything in the passing game requires Newton to hold the ball, the offensive line to hold their blocks, the WRs to run near perfect routes, and for Newton to make difficult, near perfect passes for no YAC.
    Everything, outside of our 2 minute drill or up-tempo offense, is entirely too labored. 70% of our drop backs should be quick, easy throws to WRs/TEs/RBs in space. Instead, 70% of our drop backs are slow developing, low percentage plays that even when completed/successful leads to zero after the catch ability.
    This is why I truly believe our offense will continue be inconsistent and wholly unreliable. Out of 16 regular season games, we will score 30 points...maybe once or twice, and have far too many games in the low teens.
    We have go to figure out a way to get into a rhythm offense. If you look at the league's best offenses, with the very best and most accurate QBs, greatest WRs, and Oline, less than 25% of their drop backs are what the Panthers are attempting on 70%.
    • 6