47 replies to this topic

[Grammer]

Brady, Brees, and Manning will all be old and their best years will probably be behind them.

For me,

1. Rodgers
2. Rivers
3. Freeman
4. Luck
5. Roethlisberger

[The_Cannon]

Really? Luck? Before he's even taken an NFL snap he's TOP FIVE, five years from now?

[Dpantherman]

1) Rodgers
2) Rivers
3) Big Ben
4) Shaub
5) Flacco

Granted Brees is 32 and Brady is 34, and I think they could still be at the top of their game 5 years from now. For the sake the argument, I picked younger guys.

[panther_pride11]

rodgers,rivers,big ben,ryan,freeman.
flacco could make the jump into the top five as well.

[XLR8]

1)Newton
2)Newton
3)Newton
4)Newton
5)Newton

Now tell me which one is Cam Newton?

[Grammer]

Really? Luck? Before he's even taken an NFL snap he's TOP FIVE, five years from now?

Luck is going to be a great QB. Manning was already in this range (maybe a little lower) 5 years into his career. Dan Marino certainly was the best QB from 1984-1989.

It's not as crazy as you think.

[Boltergeist]

I'd say Rodgers, Rivers, Big Ben, Schaub, and I'll go Bradford

[Varking]

Passing stats shouldn't make you the best. That being said, Rivers and Schaub will continue to put up huge numbers and produce losses in the postseason, when they get to the postseason.

Schaub can not be considered one of the best when he has the best WR in football and they have never, ever, been higher than 9-7. And that was once. So only one time in his career has his team been above 500. And after that season they went 6-10.

He has the worlds best, most consistent WR in the league and had the NFLs leading rusher last season. You can say what you want about his team having a bad defense but the truth is there are QBs out there with teams in the past that had no defense, and less to work with on offense, and they still won. The guy isn't a winner.

[TerriblePizza]

Fact: Schaub is 30 and Big Ben is 29. They'll be nearing the end of their careers. Especially with how much of a beating Big Ben takes and how fragile Schaub is.

My top ten:

1. Rodgers
2. Rivers
3. Flacco
4. Bradford
5. Ryan

[GritsRgreat]

Beck

Dalton

Rodgers

Rivers

Favre

[thefuzz]

Rivers
Rodgers
Bradford
Stafford
Freeman

[tarheelpride]

Rodgers
Rivers
Bradford
Freeman
Clausen I keed, i keed

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

I smell haters in this thread.

[HoFBound90]

Rodgers
Rivers
Stafford (maybe if he stays healthy)
Bradford
Either a current rookie or Luck will develop into a top 5 QB
Maybe Matt Ryan, he could replace stafford on my list.

Schaub puts up good numbers but isn't a winner yet and he is already getting their in age.

I like Josh Freeman but don't ever see him becoming and "elite" qb.

[panther_pride11]

i forgot about bradford,and that ben was 29.

rodgers
rivers
ryan
freeman
bradford/flacco