PhillyB

All-PRO
  • Content count

    24,586
  • Joined

  • Last visited


Community Reputation

21756 Fuggin Awesome

About PhillyB

  • Rank
    antimesoblitzomorphism
  • Birthday 08/30/1985

Profile Information

  • Gender Male
  • Location third spur east of the sun
  • Interests 19th century nautical literature

Converted

  • Location exploring

Recent Profile Visitors


19,764 profile views

PhillyB's Activity

  1. PhillyB added a post in a topic Armed white racists with Conferdate flags and pickup trucks storm a black child's birthday party   

    if al sharpton and jesse jackson stopped talking about these things they wouldn't happen
    • 3
  2. PhillyB added a post in a topic what's the maddest you've ever been as a panthers fan?   

    two of my angriest moments were the drew carter mugging on saturday night football in 2007 and cowboys game in 2009 when a deep muhsin muhammed touchdown was called back for offensive pass interference. i almost fuging destroyed the bar on that one.
    • 0
  3. PhillyB added a topic in Carolina Panthers   

    what's the maddest you've ever been as a panthers fan?
    Inspired by the Panthers vs. Seahawks replay thread.
    Mine is from that game, when Kam Chancellor jumped over the field goal unit for an attempted block, and then when we lined back up for the retry he stood in the exact same place and not one player or captain or coach ever even considered the possibility of lining someone up to block him. Sure enough, he did the same exact damn thing while I was screaming blood and carbon dioxide at the TV along with the rest of the universe, and he blocked the kick. I'm convinced the only reason I'm not dead right now is because the penalty called it back and nullified the turnover.
    Even Haruki Nakamura's boner on the Falcons hail mary in 2012 wasn't as staggeringly, avoidably, obviously fuging stupid.
    • 111 replies
    • 1,793 views
  4. PhillyB added a post in a topic Panthers vs Seahawks   

    on it
    • 1
  5. PhillyB added a post in a topic Panthers vs Seahawks   

    maddest i have ever been at any single moment during a panthers game. even madder than nakamura's cover zero against roddy white in 2012. i should have died of a brain aneurysm that night.
    • 0
  6. PhillyB added a post in a topic Ousted Saint Junior Galette's girlfriend takes to Twitter, hilarity ensues   

    holy mother of god i finally got done with that thread on SR. absolute gold.
    i remember three years ago stepping off a ship after an internetless month at sea, plugging into the wifi at a cafe in sydney, and finding out the bounty scandal had just broken. the joy that filled me was unspeakable, and i spent the next week glued to the updates laughing endlessly at their misfortune.
    nothing with ever compare to those days, but damn if this doesn't come close. this is a staggering breach of privacy and galette is a humungous ass and i would buy him a drink anyway just for ruining things for so many shrimp-scarfing swamp fans.
    • 7
  7. PhillyB added a post in a topic Ousted Saint Junior Galette's girlfriend takes to Twitter, hilarity ensues   

    who dat gone go 0-16
    • 10
  8. PhillyB added a post in a topic Vegas has Panthers at 8.5 wins   

    8-7-1 would probably win this division lol
    • 0
  9. PhillyB added a post in a topic Marines killed in TN   

    I was hoping someone would respond to my effort post :-)
    I'll agree with you on a surface level re: your two kinds of history, but I also think there's much merit in the postmodernist argument that there is no such thing is true objectivity in any pursuit of knowledge, as each pursuit is framed by the epistemology present at the time it's pursued. therefore there are multiple truths - and multiple historical truths - depending on whose memory is being sanctioned by those who produce historical memory. Because of this I disagree with your dichotomy of "political analysis rather than historical fact" as I don't think it's the binary you think it is.
    This being the case, the best thing we can do is try to be as objective as possible without blundering into the folly of enlightenment-era notions of objectivity as a pure approach, which generally means transparent methodology about how to read, write, and interpret history. Much historical work over the past half century has been about precisely this, from analyzing what it means to analyze history through the lens of presentism (culling the past to serve present needs) or historicism (attempting to assemble the facts independently of their present meaning) or historiography, which analyzes the historical change of historical writing and facts themselves.
    All this to say: the flip side of your attack on bomb scholarship as tainted by liberal academia (to whom you've failed to assign a motive for such disdainful anti-americanism) is that your defense of it is itself produced by political forces invested in the bomb drop being the right decision (or at the very least the clearly-present, obvious, manifest choice at the time, the only decision that we really could've made.)
    I've outlined what political forces have produced this defense. I've also outlined the facts that fly in the face of this narrative, and that is that multiple historical sources demonstrate a lot of internal uncertainty about the decision to drop the bomb. It wasn't the monolithic decision everyone likes to officially remember it as. And Edward Layton? Fine, maybe Edward Layton knew a lot about the Japanese and maybe Nimitz didn't oppose the bomb drop (is anyone actually suggesting he did, or is that a straw man?) But it sure as hell seems he had some misgivings about it. And even if he didn't, lots of other important people did.
    Also, your poke at college professors is laughable considering the role they played in ending the war and greasing the wheels of peace immediately post-war. And it is a source of significant debate whether or not the U.S. would've actually used the atomic bomb on Germany. 
    Finally: getting upset at men in war possibly having "bad intentions" is the precise opposite of cold, hard historical analysis. In fact, it reflects the nationalist rhetoric that rose out of the 1980s and 90s during the attempted return to patriotic values and official historical narratives that reflected those values, a tide of good feelings about America intended to combat any manner of ambiguity or dialogue about a less-than-wholly-moral American decision-making process during the Good War. Perhaps your own selection of historical facts reflects a more political base to your historical analysis than you realize.
    • 2
  10. PhillyB added a post in a topic Another mass shooting in movie theater, this time in Louisiana   

    what are you saying is the narrative?
    • 0
  11. PhillyB added a post in a topic Another mass shooting in movie theater, this time in Louisiana   

    what are you arguing here?
    • 0
  12. PhillyB added a post in a topic Seahawks offer Wilson $21M/year but Wilson wants more   

    they won't be able to pay everyone that makes that team look so good. part of their success has been in only having to pay chump change to their quarterback and spread those millions elsewhere.
    • 4
  13. PhillyB added a post in a topic Seahawks offer Wilson $21M/year but Wilson wants more   

    that roster is going to collapse if he gets paid anything north of 20m.
    • 8
  14. PhillyB added a post in a topic "Responsible gun owners" bring guns to defend military recruiting station, promptly accidentally discharges weapon   

    lol those guys look like such fuging idiots standing out there defending america. if a guy wants to go shoot up a recruitment center he's not gonna be stopped by a fat 55-year-old duck dynasty fan and his bojangles cup
    • 3