81 replies to this topic

[Zod]

Personally, I find it pathetic when fans of a team post threads about individuals that used to play for the Panthers. Its the football equivalent of google stalking your ex-girlfriend. But it seems to be a popular thing. Allow it in the panthers forum or no?

[I Registered To Post This]

How about a forums user whose entire existence is predicated on swinging from an ex player's nuts

[MHS831]

I don't have a problem when the discussion is on filling a gap as it relates to current players because the skill set is the same and a norm has been established, but Jake is a Brown and Peppers is a Bear. I don't want Peppers to succeed but I would like to see Jake go out on a high note. However, the current players are all that really matter, so don't give me the statistical updates of ex-Panthers every game. That is a bit wack.

[Humble Dew]

Damn, Zod we finally agree on something. Must be the Apocalypse....

Not a Panther anymore means NFL news. Unless they have retired a Panther and have something going on that is worth discussing.

Edited by Jangler, 15 August 2010 - 06:53 AM.

[Cyclonus]

If it's about Jake...leave it here. If it's about Peppers......NFL Forum!

[Varking]

All non-current Panthers ( meaning they aren't Panthers anymore ) should be posted in the NFL section, or the smack section. Leave this section strictly for Panthers news. It isn't hard to read and people should have been posting things in its proper place anyway.

[Hairless Cat]

NFL news.

[Darth Biscuit]

No, ex players (that currently play for other teams) should be discussed in the NFL forums, not the Panthers forums unless something about them directly relates to the current Panthers.

[jbland]

Banish all non-panthers players to the NFL forum.

[Davidson Deac II]

No explayer threads here.

[JungleCat]

It depends on whether they're retired or playing for another team. If they're not Panthers, send it to the NFL section.

[Lumps]

Thank you god. Get rid of them! This should be current panther talk only.

[Jackofalltrades]

Do not allow, you're either a Panther or you're not.

[PantherBoy95]

I guess I'll be one of the first to disagree. I think it depends obviously the situation varies. If someone eventually posts that through 6 games Peppers has been nonexistent I definitely have NO problem seeing that...it's actually something I would WANT to see and discuss. Though I would hate for it to become a FEATURED topic on the forum to the point it begins to take over, so an occasional thread that talks about the players current production is no problem to me (same reason why I read the Jake thread about him going 6-7).

But understand this is the Panthers Forum; so it's TECHNICALLY in the wrong place...

[The Saltman]

Just ban nj. There problem solved.