33 replies to this topic

[Peppers90 NC]

My brilliance/ignorance has just informed me that Visanthe Shiancoe is still a free agent. He would be a very good #2 option, almost seamlessly replacing Shockey.

I know people for some reason are high on Barnidge, but let's face it, he has been in the league for 4 seasons with little to no production to account for. There are many players with less experience that us huddlers have written off. I'm not saying get rid of Barny, but I'd feel better with a more experienced and productive player at the #2 TE spot, considering its importance in this offense.

Yes Tolbert was brought in, but he isn't a 6'4 big body receiver either. He is getting up there in age, but since it doesn't look like Shock is coming back, he looks like a viable option.

[jtnc]

No. People are too busy slobbering over Barnridge's "potential".

[Ivan The Awesome]

If they haven't signed Shockey, what makes you think that Schiacoe will be a better option?

[Car123]

Barnidge

[Peppers90 NC]

If they haven't signed Shockey, what makes you think that Schiacoe will be a better option?

viable doesn't mean better, or does it? still trying to make sense of that question

[Peppers90 NC]

Barnidge

i get it, he has done so much in his 4 years in the league.

[KendrickPanther]

Barnidge looked great before the knee injury. Now is a good time to see what he has. We expect to have a good season but Ron Ron is still in his honeymoon. The pressure to win will be intense in 2013.

[csx]

Barnidge obviously hasn't done a whole lot. However the goal of any team is to build through the draft and he's obviously a guy they seem at this point to be satisfied with. They know what they want and they know him better than any of us. I will will trust in Chud to make that decision.

[Argus Plexus]

That was last year, need more of this.

[rayzor]

considering that 3 of barnidge's 4 years were under fox who was brilliant in the way he used TEs.

that was pretty much an ideal situation for any TE, right?

and then last year was IRed so he had every chance to show he could make it as a solid TE.

[Argus Plexus]

Better view. The guy can turn on the jets and I remember seeing him in action before, the guy is hard to take down. Crap blocker but great hands.

[Ivan The Awesome]

viable doesn't mean better, or does it? still trying to make sense of that question

I'm actually trying to make sense of your answer/question for my question. It's a simple question that I asked you. If they have not signed Shockey, why would they sign Shiancoe? They are similar, both vets. Shockey would be signed way before Shiancoe simply because he's played with our unit before and knows the system. I don't understand why you would even consider Shiancoe an option.

[Peppers90 NC]

I haven't lost hope in Barny either, would love for him to pan out. Shiancoe has almost the same skill sets as Shockey, he can do the dirty work with blocking and make tough catches. I see Barny more of a guy needing space, but really, what does anybody know about Barny? We can say he didn't fit what Fox wants in a TE so that hampered his playing time, but if he really stood out in those 3 years, nobody thinks he would have gotten more opportunities? Basically, Shiancoe is a good option if we want Shockey, but he doesn't come back. I know we are developing young guys, but hey, we are making a serious run, you need vets as well.

[Peppers90 NC]

I'm actually trying to make sense of your answer/question for my question. It's a simple question that I asked you. If they have not signed Shockey, why would they sign Shiancoe? They are similar, both vets. Shockey would be signed way before Shiancoe simply because he's played with our unit before and knows the system. I don't understand why you would even consider Shiancoe an option.

From what i understand, Shockey may not want to play period, or maybe not for what we can/or have offered him. I never said Shiancoe was a better option, you are putting words in my post.