54 replies to this topic

[Zod]

We would have our choice of ten teams multiple first rounders by now.

[The Answer]

So I'm assuming you know that positively no offers have been made?






You ate the worm again didnt you...

[Lone Buc Fan]

Well Steve Smith is a top 10 receiver... Julius Peppers on the other hand, its very debatable about how consistent he is and his heart to play.

[Zod]

Well Steve Smith is a top 2 receiver...

Fixed

[The Answer]

I couldn't really rate a top 3 wide receivers because there are at least 5 wr who just have different play style and thus may affect their stats, but this would be mine in no particular order.

1. Steve
2. Fitz
3. Andre Johns
4. Calvin Johnson
5. Moss or Reggie Wayne

[DaveThePanther2008]

I couldn't really rate a top 3 wide receivers because there are at least 5 wr who just have different play style and thus may affect their stats, but this would be mine in no particular order.

1. Steve
2. Fitz
3. Andre Johns
4. Calvin Johnson
5. Moss or Reggie Wayne

The difference is year in and year out Smitty is the man. Reggie Wayne to me is second because of consistancy. Fitz 3 with both Johnsons and finally Moss. Moss is an upgraded T.O.

[Panthro]

I'd put Fitz #1, Smith #2 for now and Andre #3...but Calvin has the potential to surapass all IMHO

[top dawg]

Well, I am not exactly sure if teams would be lining up or not, if Anquan Boldin and Braylon Edwards are any indication. It would probably depend on the compensation involved. It's not like Smitty's rep is golden around the league either.

Just food for thought.

[top dawg]

Some of you would probably disagree, but Smitty and Pep fit in with this organization like a hand in a glove. Anywhere else, they would be perceived as being overpaid, but that isn't necessarily the case here. We know what we've got, and the FO is willing to pay for their services (IMHO, as well they should).

[panther4life]

Steve Smith has been the best player in our franchise history

[RockyTopVol]

Smith is the 3rd best receiver in the league. Johnson is the best (I think), and Fitz is second. I don't get why so many people want to call Calvin Johnson one of the best in the league already. He sure has the tools, and could definitely get there...I just haven't seen him prove it yet.
I agree with the thread though. Smith would be a hotter commodity than Pepp.

[Snake]

We would have had some picks for Smith just because of his consistence. He is always above 1000 yards even when we are a run first team. Pep on the other hand is a hot and cold player and IDK who defends him he takes plays off and thats why. The dude just dose not have the drive of greatness like Smith and others.

[Carolina Husker]

Smitty's great. Definitely top 5. But there is no doubt Fitzgerald is the best WR in the game today...

[mantal]

Smitty's great. Definitely top 5. But there is no doubt Fitzgerald is the best WR in the game today...

Definitely the flavor of the day, but does that actually make him #1, just because he burned us in a playoff game? Not positive on that one, the line is very small...

[X-Clown]

Definitely the flavor of the day, but does that actually make him #1, just because he burned us in a playoff game? Not positive on that one, the line is very small...

He didn't just burn us, did you watch the other playoff games?