Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Spaceballs83

And so it begins....Newton vs Luck

120 posts in this topic

As a redone threat, duhhh.

As a QB who can lead his offense every series and put points on the scoreboard, he's not there yet. He made some terrible mistakes last year.

You said "scoring position" - not leading an offense every series and putting points on the board. "scoring position" is a little further out than the red zone.

and what mistakes are u refering to? his picks? first off 17 picks is not equivalent to having a "throwing picks issue". in fact up until 2 years ago when brady started throwing for high volume values with less than 10 picks. for reference peyton manning AVERAGES 15 picks, 4200 yards and 31 TDs a year. his 2 time superbowl champion brother eli averages 17 picks a year. Brees since being in NO has averaged 15.5 picks a year as well.

now if you take away legedu, cam gets about 4 picks back that were single handedly caused by naanee- and hell even if you don't Cam is sitting in pretty good company for having ONE ROOKIE SEASON UNDER HIS BELT. 4800 yards, 35 TDs, 17 picks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I could care less what luck does.He didn't want to be a panther and we already have a great quarterback.What is he does for indy is irrelevant to me.I'm much more concerned about one of our corners or defensive tackles stepping up and solving a problem for us this year.Cam is gonna be a constant in the pro bowl.We have our qb!

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

:wacko:

Stanford. PAC 12. And they couldn't even win the Fiesta Bowl ffs.

Anyone saying a player is not a bust, before they have proven anything in a real NFL season, is just an idiot.

So we're bringing up Conference now huh? Didnt Elway come from the very same school?

Pac 12, Palmer? Drew Bledsoe? Aikman? Moon? Rodgers?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

These threads kill me. Last week it was RGIII. This week its Luck. Who's next? Matt Barkley..

Soft skin

Im not sold on RG3. And I see a lot of Jimmy Clausen in Matt Barkley.

Barkley is one guy I see as a potential BUST for sure.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You said "scoring position" - not leading an offense every series and putting points on the board. "scoring position" is a little further out than the red zone.

and what mistakes are u refering to? his picks? first off 17 picks is not equivalent to having a "throwing picks issue". in fact up until 2 years ago when brady started throwing for high volume values with less than 10 picks. for reference peyton manning AVERAGES 15 picks, 4200 yards and 31 TDs a year. his 2 time superbowl champion brother eli averages 17 picks a year. Brees since being in NO has averaged 15.5 picks a year as well.

now if you take away legedu, cam gets about 4 picks back that were single handedly caused by naanee- and hell even if you don't Cam is sitting in pretty good company for having ONE ROOKIE SEASON UNDER HIS BELT. 4800 yards, 35 TDs, 17 picks.

Make it short. As good as Cam was, he cant lead the O in back to back TD, yet. Just say hello to those Saints* D.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe that Luck will be good. He fits what is considered to be the perfect QB.

He can read defenses.

He is very accurate and protects the ball.

He has very good arm strength. Bla, boa, bla

We have Cam Newton, the Franchise QB for the Carolina Panthers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im not sold on RG3. And I see a lot of Jimmy Clausen in Matt Barkley.

Barkley is one guy I see as a potential BUST for sure.

The point is if people aren't comparing Cam to Superman, Ironman or Wonder Women most Panther fans get in a huff. Its like They actually believe he's a Hall Of Famer already. He's not even the best quarterback in the NFCS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The point is if people aren't comparing Cam to Superman, Ironman or Wonder Women most Panther fans get in a huff. Its like They actually believe he's a Hall Of Famer already. He's not even the best quarterback in the NFCS.

agree and I love Cam

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only thing worse that national media talking about a comparison between Newton/Luck is having the same discussion here!

Luck played well. The end.

Cam is our QB. The end.

It's preseason. The end.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The media cant accept a black QB being as good as Cam is. They will do everything they can to diminish what Cam has done and make absurd comparisons to white QBs. If it wasn't Luck, it would be Tannehill or some other scrub.

They will never fathom Cam being as good as peyton, brady, and rodgers and he will never get the type of media respect as they do.

retarded statement of the week

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites