Jump to content


Photo
- - - - -

So you want a new GM huh?..Check this out and maybe you'll reconsider.


  • Please log in to reply
67 replies to this topic

#1 panther4life

panther4life

    Senior Member

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 4,654 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 12:15 AM

*
A WHOLE PIE!

Here are the the guys who have been running their respective team since at least 02 and their records.

Arizona gm Graves took over in 2002 65-95(40% win percentage)
Baltimore gm Newsome took over in 02 94-66 (58% win percentage)
Carolina GM Hurney took over in 02 79-81(49% win percentage) throw out 2010 (Jerry tanked this season and everyone knows it). and he's 77-67(53% win percentage)
Cincinnati Mike Brown Owner since 91 124-244(46% win percentage)
Dallas gm/owner Jones since 89 198-170(53.8 win percentage)
New England, Bill Belicheck since 2000 139-53/(72% win percentage)up until on 09 he split power with pioli but always had final say…by himself he's 37-11(77% win percentage)
New Orleans Mickey Loomis since 02 90-70(56% win percentage)
Oakland Davis since 63 but ill start in 02 56-104 their new GM is in first year(35% win percentage)
Pittsburgh- Kevin Colbert since 2000 127-64-1. (66% win percentage)

Below is the rest

Atlanta gm Dimitroff took over in 08 and the Falcons have been 43-21 under his tenure(67% win percentage). Before him was rich mckay who started in 03 35-45(43% win percentage)…previously they had a gm but the previous owner had final say over personnel decisions. mckay was the first full time gm of the falcons after blank purchased the team in 02
2

Buffalo Buddy Nix- took over in 2010 and the Bills have a 10-22 record since he took over.(31% win percentage)Before him was Russ Brandon who went 13-19 for 2 years(08and 09)(40% win percentage), now the teams ceo and 2nd man to owner Ralph Wilson. Before Brandon Marv Levy handled the gm job for 2 years (06 and 07)the Bills record under him was 14-18(43% win percentage). Before Levy they had Tom Donahoe run things from 01 to 05, in this time frame the bills were 31-49.(38% win percentage).
4

Chicago Jerry Angelo took over in 01 and went 95-81.(53.9% win percentage) The bears hired Phil Emory to replace him this year after deciding to fire Angelo.
2

Cleveland GM Tom heckert has been there since 2010. The Browns record under him so far is 9-23.(28% win percentage) The predecessor to Heckert only lasted 8 games(yes half a season) in 09 before being fired after a 1-7 start. That gentleman's name was George Kokonis. Before him Phil Savage was the gm from 05 to 08, over those 4 years the Browns had a record of 24-40(37.5% win percentage). In the 01-04 seasons Butch Davis was the head coach and de facto gm and during this time they were 25-49.(33.7% win percentage)
4

Denver now has Elway in charge but before him Brian xanders was the gm for the 09-11 to seasons and was fired/"mutely agreed" to step down in favor of Elway going forward earlier this year. Under his 3 full seasons the team was 20-28(41% win percentage). From 02-07 Ted sundquist was the gm and did well(56-44)(56% win percentage) but shannahan had him fired after the 07 season when they went 7-9.
3

Detroit GM Martin Mayhew has been with the club since 08 and has complied 16-32 record so far.(33% win percentage) Before Mayhew the infamous Matt Millen ran the Lions front office from 01-08. His terrible tenure finally ended after he capped off the worst career of any GM with and 0-16 season. The Lions overall under Millen was a miserable 31-97.(26% win percentage)
2

Green Bay GM Ted Thompson joined the franchise in 05 and the Packers have had a 67-45 record since he joined them.(59.8 win percentage)Before Thompson Mike Sherman was the head coach/gm from 01-04(granted Ron Wolf handled the 01 draft). Sherman did well in his duel roles leading the team to a record of 44-20 in 4 seasons as gm/head coach.(68% win percentage) In 05 Sherman committed a major crime in Green Bay by having a losing record (4-12). You would have to go all the way back to 1991 to find a year where the Packers had a losing record before this happened. its only happened once since then too, in 08- they went 6-10.
2

Houston' GM Rick Smith has been with Texans since 06 and they have had a record of 47-49 since he took over.(48.9% win percentage) Previous to Smith Casserly was the only other GM of the franchise and he ran things from their first year(2002) through 2005. He had a total record of 18-46. Started with 4 wins, then 5, then 7 and in his final year they went backwards for the first time only winning 2 games.(28% win percentage)
2

Indianapolis GM Ryan Grigson is in his first year with the Colts. Before him Bill Polian joined the colts in 97 after he was given a promotion(named President of the colts vs GM of Panthers). After a terrible first year he acquired the rights to the first overall pick in the draft (Peyton Manning) in 98. Things started off slow only winning 6 games in his first 2 years but after that it was mostly smooth sailing. When it was all said and done his record their was 152-88 after his 15 years with the Colts.(63% win percentage).
2

Jacksonville's Gene Smith is the first "GM" in Jaguars history . He started in 09 and has a recored of 20-28(41% win percentage). James Lanell "Shack" Harris was the teams VP of player personnel since the teams inception. The Jags overall record under his tenure was 118-106.(52.6% win percentage)
2

Kansas city hired Scott Pioli before the 09 season. Since 09 the Chiefs have had a record 21-27 under Pioli's control. (43.7% win percentage)The chiefs previously had Carl Peterson running the team for 20 years. Under Peterson the Chief's record was 176-141-1(55% win percentage).
2

Miami GM Jeff Ireland is probably closest to being on his way out the door of any current GM. His record since taking over in 08 is 31-33.(48% win percentage)His first year the team won 11 games, then 7 the next 2 and now 6 last year. The team is a mess and Ireland has nothing to hang his hat on right now. Randy Mueller was the previous GM but only had final say for the roster in 2007. In his lone year of control the team went 1-15(.06 win percentage). In 2005 and 2006 Saban was head coach and had the ultimate say in roster decisions. He went 15-17(46.8% win percentage) during this time and then took off for Alabama when the job became available after Mike Shula was fired(yes the panthers qb coach).From 2000-2004 Rick Spielman ran the personnel decisions. The Doplhins record under this time was 45-35.(56% win percentage)
3

Minnesota- Rick Spielman took over the front office duties in June of 06,compiling a record of 45 -51.(46.8 win percentage) Granted his first draft was in 07. Before Spielman Rob Brzezinski ran the front office. He had full control from 02-06. The vikings went 43-53 during this time frame.(44.7% win percentage)
2

New York Giants current GM Jerry reese has held his position since 07 and the Giants have a record of 49-31.(61% win percentage) Ernie Acorsi was promoted from assistant GM to GM in 98 and held that title through 2006 before Reese took over. He had a record of 73-71.(50.6% win percentage)
2

New york Jets GM Mike Tannenbaum since has been there since 06 and the Jets have been 49-47 during his tenure.(51% win percentage) Terry Bradway was the Previous GM and he held the title from 01-06. His record was 39-41(48.7% win percentage).
2

Philadellpia GM Howie Rosemann has been with the team since 2010 and before was Joe banner but Reid has had final say in roster decisions since 01. Since 2001 the eagles record is 110-66.(62.5% win percentage)
1


San Diego gm a.j smith since 03 88-56(61% win percentage)
2

San fran has made a nice turnaround so far under Trent Baalke who took over in 2011. Last year they went 13-3… Before Baalke was Scott Mcloughlan who ran the front office from 05-2010. 49ERS record under him was 23-41(35.9% win percentage). From 01-05 Terry Donahue was in charge. From 01-05 the niners were 31-33(48% win percentage) but declined each year. His first year they won 12, then 10,then 7, then 2 and was promptly fired.
3

Seattle Gm John Schneider has been there since 2010. The Seahawks have been 14-18 under him after 2 years.(42% win percentage) Tim Ruskell ran things from 05-09. He had a winning record of 34-30(53% win percentage) but he inherited a 13 win team his first season(thanks to mike holmgren) and his drafting was horrible. Before that Bob whittstitt split power with Holmgren.
3

St.Louis les snead is in his first year. From 08-11 Billy Devaney ran the Rams front office and was his record is amongst the worst. The Rams went 12-52(18.7% win percentage) during this time span. Jim Zygmunt who was with the team for 27 years made personnel decisions from 00-07. During this time they were 68-60.(53% win percentage)
2

Tampa's GM Mark Dominik has held his post since 09. In this time frame the Bucs are 17-31.(35% win percentage) From 04-08 Bruce Allen was the GM.The Bucs were 41-39 under Allen(51.2% win percentage). His drafts were likely what did him in. His first round picks over those 5 years were Michael Clayton,Cadillac Williams,Davin Joseph,Gaines Adams and Aqib Talib. Of all his draft picks only Joseph,Trueblood,Black,Hayward,Talib and Zuttah remain.
2

Tennesee's Current GM Ruston Webster is in his first year with the team. Previously Mike Reinfedlt ran the team since 07 and went 45-35.Reinfieldt (56% win percentage) has been promoted to Executive VP and CEO.Before that Floyd Reese ran things for a long time(from 94-thru 06). In those 13 seasons he went 106-102.(50.9%) win percentage).
3

Washington hired GM Bruce Allen in late 09 and the Skins have gone 11-21(34% win percentage) in his 2 years of being back with the team. Vinny Cerrato was in charge of the rosters from 03 to 09. The skins went 47-65 during this span.(41.9% win percentage)
3

***I only listed regular season records

So since 02 there has been 63 different final decision makers/GM's in the NFL. Only 5 true GM'S(non-owners or belicheck) have been with their team since 02. Those guys are
Rod Graves in Arizona(40% win percentage)- 1-0 in Superbowl since 02
Ozzie Newsome in Baltimore(58% win percentage)0 Superbowl appearances since 02
Marty Hurney in Carolina (49% win percentage)0-1 in Superbowl since 02
Mickey Loomis in New Orleans(56%win percentage) 1-0 in Superbowl since 02
Kevin Colbert in Pittsburgh(66% career win percentage)2-1 in Superbowl since 02



The others who have been running their team since 02 that still are
Mike Brown in Cincinatti- 0 Super Bowl appearances since 88
Jerry Jones in Dallas- 0 Super Bowl appearances since the mid 90's
Bellicheck in New England- 2-1 In Super Bowl since 02




All in all there has been 13 Super Bowl contestants since 02 and they are listed below.
Giants 2-0-
Steelers 2-1
Patriots 2-2
Colts 1-1
Bucs 1-0
Packers 1-0
Saints****** 1-0
Cardinals0-1
Bears 0-1
Seahawks 0-1
Eagles 0-1
Panthers 0-1
Raiders 0-1


So after all that research these are who I find to be the best GM/Decision makers that were in the league through last season with their team and where I would rank them based off what they have done since they joined their team.(I stopped once I got to Hurney)
1.Bill Belicheck-(Patriots)
2.Kevin Colbert(Steelers)
3.Ted Thompson(Packers)
4.Mickey Loomis(Saints******)
5.Jerry Reese(Giants)
6.Andy Reid(Eagles)
7.Ozzie Newsome(Ravens)
8.A.J Smith(Chargers)
9.Bill Polian(Colts)
10.Thomas Dimitroff(Falcons)
11.Jerry Angelo(Bears)-recent drafts are very bad
12.Marty Hurney(Panthers)

All of those teams pretty much built their teams and relied heavily on the draft. Biggest playmakers signed in free agency that led to Super Bowl wins were Charles Woodson in Green Bay and Drew Brees in New orleans. You have to remember the teams who draft well and can retain their own don't have cap space to go and out spend on pricey free agents vs the other teams who don't fare so well in the draft.

For more on that check this very informative site out http://www.profootba...sembled-charts/ (thanks jawnyblaze)

In closing unless we can steal one of those elite guys somehow, we have a very slim chance of finding a stud to replace Hurney. Yes Baalke looks good right now and Grigson and Elway may turn out to be something but history is not kind to many new GM's over the past 10 years. Decosta gets rave reviews but he's paid very well and is the heir apparent to Newsome in Baltimore.
So while I do not find Hurney to be part of the elite crowd, I do think he is well above average even with the Armanti and even worse Everette Brown wasted draft picks. He is at a point where he is running out of excuses if we don't make some major strides in the next 2 seasons but theres plenty of reason to believe that we will be a playoff contender as soon as this season and hopefully much more in the years to come.

And yes I am hypocrite for posting another new Hurney thread. Sorry about that.

#2 ItsPantone278

ItsPantone278

    ItsPantone278

  • ALL-PRO
  • 1,851 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 02:20 AM

Good stuff. Thanks.

#3 fieryprophet

fieryprophet

    WARNING: Do not annoy!

  • ALL-PRO
  • 5,333 posts
  • LocationLa Grange, NC

Posted 15 September 2012 - 02:59 AM

I appreciate the information, and it is broken down well, but. . .(and I've said this nine millions times before. . .)

Hurney gets the players the coaches want. During the Fox era he got Fox-type players. With Rivera he's investing in Rivera-type players. So judging either way will require keeping in mind that he picks on behalf of the coaching staff far more than other GMs, who generally love to think they are smarter than their coaches and pick who they want instead of who the coaches ask for.

#4 SCMunnerlyn1

SCMunnerlyn1

    The Fuhckening has begun

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 5,623 posts
  • LocationValdosta Georgia

Posted 15 September 2012 - 03:12 AM

Props for the research .. I wish there were more threads like this.

#5 PantherPhann89

PantherPhann89

    CPP "Carolina Panther Phann"

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,375 posts
  • LocationSC

Posted 15 September 2012 - 03:31 AM

Good read...

#6 Frash Brastard

Frash Brastard

    Freddy Frashbear

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 14,790 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 03:45 AM

so all this to justify, ... what exactly? Hurney refusing to strengthen problem areas in Free Agency?

Every year like 85% of the teams have picks in the first round of the draft. Free Agency is not necessarily something you "build a team with" as much as it is a tool to help you gain a competitive advantage, and it can be a very valuable tool. The Giants for example have signed players to fill gaps that they didn't have enough draft picks to cover over the years, and they don't automatically extend every player that has started recently for them that they drafted. Just this last offseason, they let Manningham, Jacobs, and Ross walk. When you're looking at a team's talent mapped on a chart, you can't conclude just because they have more draft picks than FA acquistions on their roster makes them a team that by definition "builds through the draft". Everybody relies heavily on the draft to fill their roster. This doesn't mean that Hurney's got his finger on the pulse of what is working in the league.

#7 Frash Brastard

Frash Brastard

    Freddy Frashbear

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 14,790 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 03:49 AM

The funny thing is even if Hurney simply only signed one bona fide starting free agent a year or traded for a guy that a team would like to dump for reasons other than lack of talent (i.e. Adam Carriker, Asante Samuel, Keith Rivers) he would have a better team and he would still have enough money to sign all the core players he drafted that he would need.

#8 Stroupe-a-loop

Stroupe-a-loop

    Señor Member

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,671 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 06:21 AM

I think a lot of people are upset with this team and Hurney because they have tunnel vision and just look at the problems on this team and say "it's the only flawed team in the league" and point out our shortcomings after week 1.

Well, after the games so far:

The Saints* defense was a sieve.

The Eagles terrible offensive line is going to get their injury prone quarterback killed.

Ditto for the Bears.

Ditto once again for Green Bay.

The Bills expensive new defense can't stop a nosebleed.

Basically, in this period of free agency, you are going to have team weaknesses that are going to be exploited sometimes. It sucks, but it's hardly unique to us. Hurney isn't a moron neglecting areas of the team; it's just the nature of the league.

#9 Miaoww

Miaoww

    Senior Member

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,730 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 07:01 AM

Ah the old 'It could always be worse!' argument.

Truly the American Dream.

#10 Raleighcat83

Raleighcat83

    Senior Member

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 720 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 07:11 AM

Good post. You're never going to convince the Always Angry People though.

#11 panther4life

panther4life

    Senior Member

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 4,654 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 07:16 AM

The funny thing is even if Hurney simply only signed one bona fide starting free agent a year or traded for a guy that a team would like to dump for reasons other than lack of talent (i.e. Adam Carriker, Asante Samuel, Keith Rivers) he would have a better team and he would still have enough money to sign all the core players he drafted that he would need.

Here's starters or top backups he signed or traded for the last 2 years.
2012. Tolbert,Nakumara,Louis Murphy,Dwan Edwards,Medlock
2011.Olsen,Shockey,Applewhite,Hangartner,Jason Phillips


Thats just the last 2 years, plenty more if you go back before he was prepping for the lockout(Jerry's order's)

#12 DaCityKats

DaCityKats

    feed KB 2014

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 8,663 posts
  • LocationDa City

Posted 15 September 2012 - 07:43 AM

there are 2 division rival GMs ahead of Marty based off your research but yet we should be content that their is no one better.

#13 AceMan

AceMan

    Huddle Vet

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,765 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 08:07 AM

Ah the old 'It could always be worse!' argument.

Truly the American Dream.


The only argument that is worse is the "You're not a real fan/Find another team" one

#14 DeAngelo's #1 Fan(CRA)

DeAngelo's #1 Fan(CRA)

    Senior Member

  • Moderators
  • 26,270 posts

Posted 15 September 2012 - 08:12 AM

So AZ and Cincy are the only teams in the NFL who have kept someone around longer with a worse win %?

#15 TruCatzFan

TruCatzFan

    Phil 4:13

  • HUDDLER
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 6,470 posts
  • LocationAlaska

Posted 15 September 2012 - 08:16 AM

I'll take the Giants' percentage 50% but they have 2 Super Bowls in last few years


1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users

Shop at Amazon Contact Us: info@carolinahuddle.com