Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

redbuddha

Would Chud be a better OC?

18 posts in this topic

If we had drafted Luck rather than Cam?

I am not a Cam hater, but the excuse I keep hearing about Chud is that his adoption of the read offense/spread Cam was featured in while at Auburn, is the reason this offense is suffering know.

Since Luck came from a traditional pro style offense, Chud would not have needed to make any changes to his playcalling style.

Do you think this would have lead to the Panthers having a better record?

Do you think this would have lead to Chud not calling plays where the qb is a wide receiver/decoy?

Was Chud's history as an OC that great that his integrity can't be questioned?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He would be the exact same OC he is now. Your question is really would the Panthers perform better with Luck instead of Cam.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chud sucked year 2 in Cleveland too, and they didn't run the read option.

Chud just tries too hard to be clever.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He would be the exact same OC he is now. Your question is really would the Panthers perform better with Luck instead of Cam.

No I think that Chud is inherently flawed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

While I do think Cam being a totally different type of QB from what he is use to may have had an impact in year one, especially with the lockout reducing the time they had to work together, at this point it should not be an issue. He had a whole season followed by a whole offseason to figure things out for this year and the beginning of the season was a disaster.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe Chud would have been horrible in his 2nd year as the Panthers HC, no matter the qb that was out there. He outsmarts himself. He did get better as the year went on, so I can't wait to see how he does in his third year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chud sucked year 2 in Cleveland too, and they didn't run the read option.

Chud just tries too hard to be clever.

I really think this is it. He outthinks himself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chud was a OC with the Browns for 2 years, I believe he was replaced during his second year after the HC was fired.

Chud had one of the best offenses last year, this year teams had tape and were able to shut us down, I believe a lot factored into it. The offensive line was not up to par, missing what Shockey brought to the table, Louis Murphy learning a new system and teams adjusting to what we do on offense.

Year 3, Chud better bring it. Offensive line will be better with Kalil back and Amini with a year under his belt. Chud was able to get the offense going for the second half of the season, compared to the 1st half of the season. I really believe teams had tape on us and were able to adjust better to what we did, I also believe that the offense line was at fault for the reason we were struggling on offense. Chud is still a fairly new Play caller, 4 years of play-calling and game planning. And in one of those years he was replaced during the season.

I believe Chud will learn from his mistakes and improve as the offense progresses and we will be a better offensive team next year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chud just tries too hard to be clever.

I have to agree, I'm am amazed Chud hasn't had cam line up as an extra line man or te.

I'm sure I can count the number of times Peyton, Russell, Robert, Eli, Andrew, lined up at any position other than QB.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yeah really dumb idea. Star players will be getting thrown out for incidental contact that the ref "misunderstands" as a helmet shot. The solution isn't adding more rules or "being stricter" so to say but enforcing the rules that are already established down the middle. Our games are evidence enough that the refs suck but damn I got tired watching other teams play and see the game decided on either bullshit flags or lack of flags. If anybody needs to be punished more it isn't the players but these POS refs the league can't get their heads noses out of the asses of. Always an excuse or some convoluted reason why the refs were right. I actually heard the announcers calling it out tons of these obvious blown calls and yet still the league stands behind the refs like idiots.
    • First I got to say, damn, people trying to instantly make us the most hated team in the league, even over the Patriots aren't they lol. With all the hate Cam already gets then add Kap even if briefly, oh lord I'd hate to picture it. Yeah that first play is what stands out to me the most. I'd expect even a rookie QB to make that read and throw the ball instead of handing it off. That drive ended up in a safety where as if he throws it to Torrey Smith it is easily a 1st down and possibly a TD as he only has to beat one man. I don't even see Kap look around any in that clip so even more so it feels like he gave it away that it was a run play and the Rams read it like a book. I don't feel like we need him nor do I feel like he is better than what we have. As for his protest, I didn't like what he was doing when he was kneeling but hey he had the right to do it. I personally think him putting his money where his mouth was, was a better way than just kneeling and I commend him for doing so. To be honest the 49'ers have said they would welcome him back. Let's not forget he would still be with them had he not voided his own contract. Somebody will sign him though I just don't see it as a starter which is what he clearly wanted to try and be by voiding with the 49'ers.
    • I feel like this is some kind of guilty admission lol and you should feel bad for voting for that Lunatic / traitor president of ours.    But guess what, you will get a chance to redeem yourself in 2020 with more information about the disgraced president  coming out every week.