Smith is best Panther of all time, sorry. From the earlier discussion where people were threatening to fight each other IMO Panthers per year on every team:
12: Luke or Chuck
The biggest problem with Smith's resume going into consideration in Canton was his best years going down the shitter half of the time. 04 out for year. 06 O line falls apart and Jake sucks before getting hurt and Dan Henning sucks. 07 Jake gets hurt early in season. 09 the beginning of the end for Jake's career. 2010 erased from memory.