Wundrbread33

Stroud’s pockets are essentially playing against a team with no defensive line. Tough to evaluate. Clearly he has arm talent but I need to see more adversity.

Yeah his floor is having to transition to another position. A floor that low is horrifying.

When I turned the game on in the 2nd half, Penn St. was getting bodied all over the field. Stroud had perfect pockets, he missed some throws, and I saw a perfect dime to Harrison down field. I basically learned nothing new. Everyone knows he has a nice arm. He has good size. He’s accurate in his current situation. I didn’t get a chance to see things I need to see to evaluate a QB. Sounds like I could have seen him against some adversity in the first half, but I missed that.

Yes. He will be overdrafted if people apply the Josh Allen rational to him. Richardson is Cam if Cam was as bad a passer as F-150’s said he was.

Bridgewater completes 70% of his passes. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out he’s one of the most accurate passers in NFL history… …It’s more complicated than that.

No idea but if we score 30 I’m gonna lose my poo, be completely irrational all next week and absolutely horrible to debate with.

He’s absolute best move right now is to be a good teammate, support PJ, and show maturity in his current situation. He knows he played poorly, so playing poorly and being immature about PJ playing isn’t an option. So he’s doing the only thing he can, and there’s nothing wrong with that imo.

You know, I really think Corral is talented, so if we go QB, Levis would make sense because he may have the biggest boom/bust factor in the draft. One of them is bound to do something.

Quoting so @Jackie Lee can see it

Josh Allen opposite Burns. Wonder what that would cost…

Yes. I agree he hurt his foot.

At least you admit that when you speak in absolutes, that’s just how you convey your opinions. It’s a rather abrasive way to do so, but now I know the baseline.

So without knowing who will be the head coach, who will be the coordinator/QB coach, what offense they prefer to implement, never speaking with Fitt or Morgan, nor the scouting department… This is a fact?

You do this a lot; where you speak in absolutes and ask people to go above and beyond to show proof of things that ultimately don’t matter anyway. If you spoke in probabilities then the conversation is fine, but you don’t do so. The Tom Brady example is tiresome, but useful because everyone knows about it. A fan could have been excited about Tom in the 6th round, and another fan could oppose them saying “How many QB’s in the 6th round have lasted in the league at all let alone won a Super Bowl. Short list. Therefore Tom won’t be anything.” And then he did it. The past can be fun for conversation, but it doesn’t really matter. Like Ohio St. quarterbacks suck in the NFL…until one doesn’t. Being “realistic” would be saying, “it’s highly unlikely that Corral, coming off an injury with, likely, a new coach, would get a chance on this team.” Not absolutes. The closest thing to an absolute, is that you, and me, aren’t as knowledgeable as we think we are.

Bingo. Also that makes Richardson look even more raw as a passer. Oof.

I saw a quarterback out of sync and under duress. Not even absolving him; he missed throws. I’m just not weighing it more than years of college film.

“I saw him play NFL football and he sucked” is probably the best you will get from that Linville guy. Not much detail, very basic and emotional, demonstrated a lack of understanding (or effort reading) about the thread as a whole, all while saying I was the one not thinking critically. Impressive in a certain way.

The entire point of my thread was evaluating Corral (current player on our roster) to the quarterbacks we may decide to use a top 10 pick on…

I think it’s safe to say that there are people who give great weight to Corral’s 3 quarters of preseason play, and see the results as being on him, and there is another group who either don’t place much weight on it, or simply look deeply at the context of the situation (or spreading blame to coaching, oline, reps, etc). And at this point, there’s no convincing the other side they are right or wrong.

Huh? What’s that have to do with the post you quoted?

Thoughtful post. Post more often!

Not enough data to back up that claim. Also there are plenty of freak athlete big dudes who just don’t football well enough to make it in the league, foot locker career or not. Judging Corral off last preseason is incomplete and shortsighted to say the least.

Someone does not like them some Matt Corral. Oof.

He does throw it quite deep.