kungfoodude

I am not even certain Hunt/Lewis are core players because they came on massive contracts. Likely the last contracts they will get here, TBH. I love TMac but let's not call that shot quite yet. Especially at that position. I also question the entire scouting department. Makes me wonder if we even have people in the building capable of making good hires there.

At this point in their careers, substantially.

I gotta be honest, I cannot recall a WR we have drafted recently with so few fundamentals. It's shocking.

Oh yeah, that really is telegraphing the whole situation. Makes me wonder if he gave it an offseason to see if we turned around and then after seeing it all said, "fug this" when there was a way out. I missed that little blurb. Wow.

XL can literally do nothing that Deebo nor DK can. He doesn't blow by people consistently. He isn't physical after contact. He can't break tackles consistently. He isn't elusive. He cannot catch consistently. He has no sense of body control whatsoever. He loafs on too many reps when he isn't the target. It's not an us problem, it is a him problem. This is the same as TMJ or Mingo or any of the other recent bums. People always say it's us because it's easier than admitting we just wasted another pick and fuged up...again. I am here to tell you, eventually you will see what a lot of us already basically did last season. He ain't an NFL player. Just another in a long line of Panthers bad draft picks.

Practice Squad.

Yeah, I am not knocking Renfrow. I think his ceiling is fairly low even in a better situation. He has a lot of rust to knock off to even see if he has anything left in the tank. TBQH, the fact that it was just "us or bust" kind of let's me know that competitive just really isn't there like maybe it once was. Oh well, still better than Legette and some of these other rostered bums. Did he? I don't recall that. Link? Why would he be friends with JJ? They never played on the same team.

The fact that we don't attempt to scheme him anything open in space regularly(Debo-esque, say) let's me know they also don't think he is capable of that. Coker can't get back soon enough.

I very much doubt it had anything to do with JJ. Moreso that his wife and he wanted to be back in Minny. Plus, I have no doubt he wanted to leave the game on a contending team, at least.

Fair. But I do agree with him, likely AT catches at least one if not both of those balls. For a couple of reasons, probably get better separation, averaged 3 yds in 2024 and 2.9 yds in 2023 versus the 1.79 yds in the game today for Hunter. Additionally, AT is a physically far larger and has a significant catch radius advantage over Renfrow. That's not to say that Bryce still didn't miss those throws but those bigger guys do help alleviate some of those mistakes just because of those type of advantages. You said yourself, we are having him basically attempt to be an AT clone when he just simply isn’t.

Well for starters he was not the GM during the 2017 NFL Draft. You want me to fill in the rest of the obvious omissions?

He is literally good at nothing. Fun fact, per NFL Next Gen Stats he had the third highest catch percentage for a WR among qualifying players in 2024 and was 5th in 2023. You are starting to sound like a JT O'Sullivan sock account, brother. Questioning AT's hands is a pretty odd hill to die on.

So you don't have time to do anything but cherry picking but you want me to compile the track record of 32 teams GM's across almost 60 years of NFL history? Seems reasonable. How about I just let you continue to live the delusion that Marty Hurney was a good GM?

I did say similar about the starters on this team this week, if you recall. It's a rough look at that roster.

I couldn't be much worse, that's for sure.

I find it odd you aren't including his entire draft history.

His hit rate was not as stellar as that. It's just that his hits were some of the best in franchise history. He is just a less floaty turd in comparison to the other turds we have had as a GM.

I don't think anyone expected it to be THIS bad.

He isn't an NFL WR. That's the biggest issue.

Competitive will still TBD for this season. I had predicted all offseason we were a 4-7 win team and I am really all about the "how does it look." Right now, terrible. Also wanted answers on Bryce, Ikey, XL, young guys, offseason additions, etc. Right now, Bryce has been answered. He isn't the guy. I am fine with that, better to know now and pivot quickly in the offseason. The rest of the questions.....well....not great so far. Lots of games left. Hopefully we get to see some sense of direction.

Had ample chances to fix that and have only made one real attempt, Bozeman, who was ultimately below average.

The thing we need to be concerned about is that it was a close battle that Mays lost. It's time to draft a fuging center.

No he wouldn't. He struggles to do the most simple poo any NFL WR should know. In Game 1, TMac was far more impressive than the entirety of XL's NFL career. It's because XL doesn't do anything well at all. Well, not on the football field, for sure.

No, XL's flaws all come from him not being an NFL caliber player, like many Panthers WR draft picks before him. Like I said, I don't really put much stock into those preseason reps at all. Never have.

I believe it is "hands off" publicly but I believe it is far less so behind closed doors. He does not strike me as a man who has the ability to not micromanage. His background certainly doesn't suggest it.