190 replies to this topic

[Mage]

As in, in all, complete honesty?

Robert Griffin

This has nothing to do with how I feel about Newton by the way and even if I think RG3 is better, I still wouldn't trade Cam for anything short of something out of this world. I think Newton is still going to become an elite quarterback.

But RG3 is looking phenomenal. Accuracy, pocket presence, touch, everything.

I see all three of these guys having years though where it's a huge debate on who is better and it could be argued for any 3 of them.

[Frizzy350]

Cam has the most upside. Not over yet but his rookie year has been better than these guys individualistically.

However I would take the Seahawks, Redskins and Indy's coaching and backroom staff hands down.

IDK about that one with Pete Carrol. First he cheated pretty badly at USC and completely dodged any bullets by getting out before the hammer fell. Now he's feeding bull semen and powerthirst to his cornerbacks to make them grow taller.

[nctarheel0619]

I'm picking Cam. No question, no concern, no regret. He has every single tool, and when he gets a coaching staff that let's him play quarterback instead of glorified fullback he'll be the best in the NFL.

God, I hope you are right. He's got the work ethic too and he wants to be great.

[KissMyConverse]

Cam Then Bob Then Luck

Btw Bob looks like Coolio I have no idea who Ed is

[nctarheel0619]

These types of threads are pointless. Cam is our QB whether you like it or not. Whether you desire another QB or not.

I was waiting for this poo. It was a question asked simply. I like Cam and like him as our QB. I was asking other Panthers fans who would they have right now knowing what they know now. Just answer the question. If you don't like it, don't come in here and post something that has 0 to do with the thread. Steer clear and move along.

[Ivan The Awesome]

Cam Then Bob Then Luck

Btw Bob looks like Coolio I have no idea who Ed is

[The_Mango55]

Luck throws a crapload of picks. Rg3 is captain check down and is bound to get injured. I love Wilson for homerisric reasons but overall I like Cam best.

[nctarheel0619]

Cam Then Bob Then Luck

Btw Bob looks like Coolio I have no idea who Ed is

Google It. Looks kind of like Bob.

[Ivan The Awesome]

I was waiting for this poo. It was a question asked simply. I like Cam and like him as our QB. I was asking other Panthers fans who would they have right now knowing what they know now. Just answer the question. If you don't like it, don't come in here and post something that has 0 to do with the thread. Steer clear and move along.

Original question...

"Who would you choose for the next 5 years? Russel Wilson, Cam Newton, Andrew Luck, or Ed from Good Burger Aka Bob Griffin"


My answer stands, it has plenty to do with the thread.

[CPF4LIFE]

His accuracy is my biggest gripe, but he's been making some amazing throws the past couple of weeks.

Still needs to work on those overthrows...'specially for ole' Smith at 5'9

We need a big fast receiver for him.

[nctarheel0619]

Original question...

"Who would you choose for the next 5 years? Russel Wilson, Cam Newton, Andrew Luck, or Ed from Good Burger Aka Bob Griffin"


My answer stands, it has plenty to do with the thread.

You said Cam is our QB and didn't give any reasons why but that. Kind of lame, sir. You at least could've gave reasons why you don't like the others. Or why you like Cam so much. "He's our QB." Is common sense.

[Davidson Deac II]

Probably Luck, but I do thnk Cam has the toolsl to become a very good qb. Luck just appears to be better in the clutch, and able to handle the pressure a little better. Probably a result of a couple of extra years in college.

But the man thing I want is to win some superbowls, and you don't necessarly have to have the best qb to do that, you just need a good one.

[Ivan The Awesome]

You said Cam is our QB and didn't give any reasons why but that. Kind of lame, sir. You at least could've gave reasons why you don't like the others. Or why you like Cam so much. "He's our QB." Is common sense.

What's lame is that you need more of a reason than he's our QB. He was drafted by the Panthers. What MORE do you need? Red zone threat, cannon for an arm, height, speed, size, strength, hard to tackle, game changer. Is that enough? lol. He's your QB, stop it already.

Besides it's in the ten huddle commandments, thou shalt not covet other QB's. Oh and I think there's one that says, Thou shalt not make asinine threads. Don't quote me on that though.

[CPF4LIFE]

I dont have anything against people for rolling with Luck, he has been groomed from the start (for the NFL more specifically), Cam started out sitting behind Tim freakin The Golden Calf of Bristol then how to go play at a junior college before ending up playing big boy football which was only really preparing him in terms of competition and talent. He is still learning how to be a NFL pro QB and when he does he will be one of the best.

[nctarheel0619]

What's lame is that you need more of a reason than he's our QB. He was drafted by the Panthers. What MORE do you need? Red zone threat, cannon for an arm, height, speed, size, strength, hard to tackle, game changer. Is that enough? lol. He's your QB, stop it already.

Besides it's in the ten huddle commandments, thou shalt not covet other QB's. Oh and I think there's one that says, Thou shalt not make asinine threads. Don't quote me on that though.

This was just an opinion from everybody thread. If you looked what I posted first I said I would take Cam. So, in 2005 if this was made. And I said Tom Brady, Payton Manning, or Jake Delhomme you would've chose Jake Delhomme? That's nice.