190 replies to this topic

[rodeo]

I like Cam, but just to play devils advocate, Cam had similar interception numbers in his rookie year. Cam had 17 interceptions in 517 pass attempts in his rookie season. Right now, Luck has 16 in 503 attempts. Luck throws it a lot more, while Cam runs the ball a lot better. But it is Cam's ability to throw and his performance in crunch time that will be the key regarding his becoming an elite qb.

They had similar interception numbers, yes, but Cam had a better TD to INT ratio. Plus Luck has 4 more games to throw 3 picks each in.

[Gabeking]

It's sad that kenan doesn't even want to be associated with kel anymore :/.. But IMO based on pure upside and long term potential it's cam all the way, but if you were to ask me who is the best RIGHT NOW it's RGIII because he's doing spectacular things, but the offense that's built around him is making him look like the GOAT compared to cam and the offense he is in right now (the offense isn't built around him as much as it is around chud's wet dreams with cam in it) and anyone who is questioning his character or intangibles of leadership or whatever needs to open there eyes more and stop licking ESPN's balls

[shinallsm]

I'd probably go with Luck as much as I like Cam.

[SCP]

I think Gruden is gonna choke on Griffin's dick tonight. Good lord.

[SCP]

Cam 1-0 against Griffin

[TheOldBreed]

I would take Cam+Indy coaching staff. People around here are like an ugly dude who has a really hot chick, but for some reason thinks he can do better. Cam is the fuging future; he's like a swiss army knife....he can do it all. He just needs some better damn coaching.

[CarolinaNut]

Exactly what's special about 17 TDs to 16 INTs? What Cam did his rookie year was far beyond anything Luck has done.

he's getting it done at the end of games..keep looking at the stats though

[C47]

I'm assuming I would have a coach that I wanted to. If that's the case I would take David Shaw or another coach who would run pro style offense, and Cam. He's bigger, stronger, has better arm strength, and far more upside then the others...

[Ken]

Some people here are way over rating Luck's season. He's made some awful post snap reads and is inaccurate, especially down the field.
Now will he improve, logic says he will but there is no way you can say Luck>RG3 or Wilson who are better passers right now.

[CatMan72]

I said reasons why. Not one word answers.

Cam will develop into a better all around QB than any of those other guys. Can move around like RG3 and throw like Luck.

[CatMan72]

I think Gruden is gonna choke on Griffin's dick tonight. Good lord.

LOL, ESPN crowned RG3 "Mr. Monday Night" on FB.

Greatest 163 yard passing performance of all time, good thing Morgan bailed Mr. Monday Night out on that fumble...

[Smitty Is Our Savior]

I'd choose Cam, but I think Luck will have the best career.

All 4 will be successful in the NFL though.

[Wine&Cheese]

Honestly, I'd rather have Luck or RG3 but we have Cam and I'm OK with our QB situation. Cam has the potential to be a great player if he had a better attitude. The other two guys just seem to get IT as a player and leader. I like Wilson's demeanor and leadership skills too but I'm not sure if I'd trade Cam's meseureables and potential for him.

[Wine&Cheese]

"Welcome to Good Burger, home of the Good Burger. May I take your order?" Hahaha!

[panthersphan]

You guys are all delsional

I'd take Andrew Luck over almost ever QB in the NFL right now.

1. Luck
.
.
.
2. Cam
3. Robert Griffin
.
.
.
4. Tannahill
5. Wilson