25 replies to this topic

[King Taharqa]

Congrats Bob on being Rookie Of The Year. Get well soon. AP reports Bob received 29 votes, Luck got 11, Russell Wilson got 10.

[KillerKat]

Wilson got robbed

[TheRed]

Wow even Luck got more votes than Wilson, what gives?

The Griffin hype machine was too strong I guess. I think he had a great year, but Russell was better.

[AggieLean.]

Congrats Bob!

He deserved it. Only thing that annoyed me was Luck getting more votes than Wilson. Wilson's stats were way better than young Andrew's.

[BigSyke]

wilson deserved it to me he beat all of them.......

[footballisasport]

RG, Wilson, Luck...In that order.

[g5jamz]

Wilson outperformed RG3...period.

[King Taharqa]

Wilson outperformed RG3...period.

The writers didnt think so. One won his division, the other did not.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

The writers didnt think so. One won his division, the other did not.

One played in a much tougher division and won a playoff game against the OROY. Not that i disagree with RG3 being chosen. Your line of reasoning is simply flawed.

[thatlookseasy]

I thought RG3 was better in the regular season- he was a playmaker from week 1 whereas Wilson was a game manager for the first few weeks before coming on strong later in the season

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

Pete Carroll was robbed. Did a better job in a much tougher division with a much tougher schedule.

Wait could not the same thing be applied here? Walking contradiction strikes again.

[King Taharqa]

Wait could not the same thing be applied here? Walking contradiction strikes again.

Russell Wilson is "coach" of the Seahawks? He got that defense and special teams to play as hard as it did? As the earlier poster posted, he was a game manager for the first half of the season, while RG3 carried his team on his back all year. Is it possible I think Pete Carroll's coaching job > Russell Wilson's rookie year. Is it possible Rg3 > Wilson as QB, while Carroll > Shanny.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

I'm arguing with you for the sake of it honestly. I think RG3 deserved it.\


EDIT: A case can definitely be made for Wilson.

[Keith Moons Liver]

Wilson will have plenty of time to win his own awards. This is probably the last time RG3 will play enough games in a season to win one.

[Harris Aballah]

if pagano hadn't hoaxed everybody with his made up illnesses and late night phone calls to Luck he would have won oroy. Seriously though being from kentucky its hard to say anything nice about the colts. But thier stinky no good nameless roster and coaches was a far higher climb to the playoffs in my opinion. Skins and seahawks had a somewhat stable structure. The colts had lost everything but Wayne.