Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Hawk

North Korea

186 posts in this topic

The Japanese mainland was never invaded

The Phillipines battles were originally to push the Spaniards out. Once it became obvious that the Americans planned to annex the islands, then the Filipinos and Americans turned to battle. General Elwell Otis mistakenly believed the insurgency was close to being defeated (kinda like Cheney and his "last throes" comment.)

The fighting stopped because of political progress, not the military defeat of one side.

In Korea, again, western warfare concentrates on conquering and holding land. The US could have occupied the entire peninsula, but would not have "won" any more than it "won" by occupying all of Iraq.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Japanese mainland was never invaded because they surrendered after we beat them in every battle from December of 1942 on and completely destroyed their country from the air. An invasion would have been a bloody mess, but we would have won, just as we did on Okinawa.

The diplomatic progress you refer to in the philippine war happened in large part due to success on the battlefield, and unfortunately use of some tactics that were rather brutal in nature.

As far as Korea, had the chinese not become involved, and we occupied entire peninsula, we would have done the same thing we did in South Korea, hand power over to an elected government and all of the peninsula would likely look as South Korea does today. And under the circumstances we were fighting, that would have been a win and for that matter the best outcome for all concerned parties, especially the North Koreans.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They fired a few short range missiles today into the ocean.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

North Korea may not have the technology but they have the crazy and the desperation to just do something that can set other tensions ablaze.

They are going through a famine now with all the sanctions...widespread reports about cannibalisim and murdering one's children for meat. Even to the point that SK want to assist in a humanitarian effort.

And you thought that eating dog was crazy.

I lived in SK when I was 5-6 as my dad was stationed there. We lived in some giant mansion with a steel gated door, intercom and had a live in maid.

You are well aware of and at all times as there used to be daily bomb drills where you have to inside and off the streets so a mall would look like a flash mob just walked in. You hear the second siren for the all clear and can resume your day.

Also there was a 10 or 11 pm lights out manditate in the city. Aside from a small light you had to shut off all lights or get fines.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

this is close to a tipping point.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

this is close to a tipping point.

Not really. Don't get me wrong, they definitely need to be watched, but the tipping points generally come with things that don't make CNN headlines. For example, if they started loading up their tanks and support vehicles and moving them closer to the border with South Korea, that might be a tipping point. Or if they start fueling multiple rockets and preparing them for launch. Or if they start evacuating key personnel out of their major cities. The verbal diarrhea they continually spout is interesting and bears watching, but its not necessarily a precursor to something more sinister happening.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They fired a few short range missiles today into the ocean.

And missed. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites