I think the point here is that adopting a culture of overbearing parents that control whatever they do until they are married (or even beyond) isn't ideal, period.
It will lead to more mental health issues than america already has.
i don't know enough about mental health stats and causes to really opine on it honestly, but i think to really gain an understanding you'd have to look at varying cultural factors. certainly you could argue that standard american culture families (i can't think of a better term, i admit that one sucks) suddenly adopting general asian standards of child-rearing would cause major conflict among their peers unless everyone adopted those same standards.
other than that i can't begin to say anything on the topic for certainty, and from the get-go i think a conversation about it would have to differentiate between age groups to come up with anything concrete