First round is BPA, period, regardless of position. We are too poor of a franchise to be saying "we're good" at any, repeat ANY position. We can easily move on from bookmarks like Sanders a Blackshear. Super easy, no sweat.
Chuba is playing like an above average back. He's not, nor ever will be a Jonathan Stewart, DeAngelo Williams or CMC. He's more of a Nick Goings or Anthony Johnson. Sure, he'll get you 1000 yards in a season, but is that the best we can do?
I agree Brooks is done. We won't give up on him in the near term, but penciling him in for a roster spot in 2025 would be a colossal blunder.