Seltzer

You didn't even attempt to answer the question

100%. We are not magically going to not be a bottom dwelling team this year. The rational (and IMHO) healthy think to do is hope Bryce and the rookies continue to show improvement and we are competitive.

Thank you! That is a fair take. I genuinely think some of these posters must be miserable in their personal lives... they just can't be happy and they are determined to drag everyone else dowm

So, so many people that use to be active on here all gone... and it's bc it's just too much man... It's is completely fine critiquing Bryce. Some of this is objective nonsense though. It just is. We ain't putting up 30 points a game with this group. Having that expectation is insanity. We're going to lose more games. But it's to the point where you can't even enjoy a win on here... it's effing sad

Other than Coker on 3rd down, where are all these bad misses?? The ball was on time and where it needed to be most of the time. Zero turnovers. Got a TD taken away for bs I don't know why some people are still Panthers fans. I get not thinking Bryce is the future. Some of this hate is straight irrational and insufferable though... it just is. I'm done again for the day. It's insane Panthers fans happy about a win cant even post without being attacked by this nonsense

Thank you. Any other QB winning down 2 lineman and with 3 rookies starting would never, ever get this hate, especially against a good defense. Anyone who can't see that Bryce is playing better (even after we traded away our nominal WR1) is just hating. It's embarrassing. Just enjoy the win

If this was Patrick Mahomes playing with 3 rookies and down 2 Olineman, the announcers would be reminding the audience of that every 5 minutes... I want to engage here, and I'm definitely not on the Bryce is the savior bandwagon, but some of this stuff is objectively stupid given the context and just insufferable. I am proud of this team. We lose this game every single time the last 5 seasons

True statement. It definitely feels that long

We have the worst defense in the league and are starting rookies at literally all the skill positions outside of RB. Can't we not be happy for one day? A win is a beautiful thing in the NFL no matter what. The team has resiliency, and hopefully it bodes well for the future

100% Get the eff out with the negativity today. We lose that game every time for the past 5 seasons. Ugly, ugly, beautiful win!!!!

That's a horse collar

I'm glad to see him in this position

Completely fair take... just can't understand the straight hate when Bryce is playing good with a bunch of rookies. Nobody nationally follows this team. If this were ARod playing like this with rookies, he would be glazed for producing with nobodies... any rational NFL viewer should be able to admit that

Absolute hospital ball. Certainly not a dirty play by Mike Jack

This is why so many oldtimers don't engage as much... We get it... Bryce has been a disappointment so far being a number 1 pick. But seriously, it's embarrassing for us that have actually watched the NFL for 30+ years to see some of these takes... He's playing with all rookies and looking competent... given the circumstances, Bryce has played really well

Hell yes he has. We literally have all rookies starting at the skill positions. Very good all things considered

Over the past 5 seasons, there's a 90% chance that drive didnt end in a TD with those penalties. They showed a lot of resiliency there, regardless of who it was. JT Sanders has made such a difference for Bryce. He looks like a different QB.

By no means saying this will happen, but 2 drafts like that is how you go from one of the worst teams in the league to a contender. It's also why this bullshit of needing 7 years to rebuild is just that... You can completely change the trajectory of a team in the modern NFL in 2 years max if you have the right GM, coach, and QB

Anyone not impressed by what Dan Morgan has done so far is either willfully ignorant or just has been so scarred by the last 7 years that they instinctively think everything is bad. This already looks like one of the best drafts in franchise history, and we needed worse than anything given the state of the roster Fitterer left. Hell, it's not hyperbole to say DM got more out of this draft than everyone of Fitterers combined

It was a bad Saints team for sure, but I'm not taking anything away from this draft class. XL, Wallace, Sanders, & Coker is already better than any draft Fitterer ever had. And we get Brooks next week. This team still has a LONG ways to go to being competitive on an ongoing basis, but this was objectively a great win given where the team is at. And it's fair to be excited about this rookie class. We need another one like this to overcome the damage of the previous regime's though, for sure

Coker and Wallace were the only 2 bright spots from yesterday. Coker looked like he could be WR3, and Wallace (despite a few rookie bumps), looked like he could be our starting MLB (and I'm definitely on board with going back to a 4-3 and think Wallace can be even better in a 4-3) The only thing positive I can say about Mingo is he has been good as a run blocker so far. He's not a good receiver. Coker should get more reps from Mingo going forward. It's interesting (and sad) that 2 of the better WR's we've drafted in the past decade or so were UDFA's (Coker & Philly Brown), while we've busted on so many guys drafted high

Dalton made the playoffs 5 straight seasons. He was the #6 rated passer in 2022 (at least by PFF). Smokes & mirrors??? GTOH with that nonsense. Dalton has always been a pretty good QB, and he's in a scheme now that obviously fits his strengths. And now playing behind an elite Offensive line, Dalton has unlocked DJ & XL into looking like a legit starting WR combo. He's 36 & still has plenty of tread left on the tires. He is our QB, period, as far as I'm concerned. Absolutely nothing could be better for this franchise in the wake of Young's benching... and this is the best thing right now for BY9 also. I've never seen more of a positive turn around in the perceived trajectory of this franchise than over the past 2 weeks. I'm convinced there's a segment of this fanbase that has a pathological need for doom & gloom... Why can we not just be happy & celebrate the fact that we finally have a good offense that we should be able to sustain with this Oline group under contract together (all of them through next year) and some beyond that. Once we fix the defense, this will be the best team we've had post-Cam.

Agree 100%. Given the chaos of the past few years, it has been easy to point to the idea of just keeping Wilks. And I do think he did an admirable job during his time as interim head coach. Still, I have to give Tepper credit for this... I think Canales is a good hire, not only as a head coach & culture builder, but as an innovative play caller. He fits what modern NFL offenses need to do. Running the ball will always be important. But as we saw with Bryce (and with most of our QBs/schemes over the past 6 years), if you can't throw the ball effectively (as well as challenge deep), you are not going to succeed as a top team. Canales has not perfect (still questioning the lack of preseason playing time), but guys are getting schemed open in a way I can't remember since Dan Henning designed his offense around Smitty. Canales is putting DJ & XL in positions to make catches. The Oline is blasting open holes for the RB's more often than not. For a team that has been the epitome of putrid on offense for more seasons than I care to remember, this has been a breath of fresh air!

It's like what happened in the mountains... it happened, it's over, and all you can do is move forward. Dwelling on the past changes nothing... and regardless of anything & everything, the future here looks far more promising than it did 2 weeks ago. Having a QB playing like Dalton does mitigate this situation 1000x over though for sure. The whole goal is to find a QB. The way we did isn't ideal, and giving up all that draft capital for BY9 sucks ass no doubt, but it's not the end of the world. Teams miss on QB's... it just happens.

100%. Dalton really did save this team from the abyss. With Dalton playing, you can legitimately see the vision Dan Morgan had for the offense. This offense is built for a QB to succeed in, it just happened the guy we drafted to do that simply couldn't. And here's the thing... the NFL moves on. The Niners gave up almost as much for Trey Lance as we did BY9. It didn't work out, and they moved on. I think Bryce is in the best situation we could be considering everything that has happened. Let him sit and see if he can develop and regain his confidence. But the focus right now and for at least the intermediate future should be on Dalton. He's playing at a very high level. I have no interest in any other QB right now with how well Dalton is playing. It's that good. And Dalton is "only" 36. I mean that without hyperbole. Dalton could easily be the starter here for several more seasons given the current circumstances. Look at late-career Kurt Warner or Carson Palmer. Hell, Matt Stafford for that matter. Aaron Rodgers is 4 years older. My point being Dalton isn't on his last legs. And that's really what you're looking for as a team, no matter how you get there. We are still a year away from being truly competitive with the defensive issues & injuries, but you can at least see a plan for the first time in years. And Dalton is arguably the most important (if not unexpected) piece of that. All Hail the Red Rifle!!