It's hard to say I've watched a Panthers season where literally one guy prevented the team from winning or making the playoffs. Even when Clausen played for that one year 2010, we didn't have a great team around him. Julius Peppers left to play for the bears, Jon Beason was wearing down, so the defense wasn't that spectacular. On offense we still had Double Trouble and Smitty. (But no TE) So I don't know.