If you had to choose...

[just dave]

If Cam can continue to learn and study to where he can quickly read defences and get through his progressions he will be something else. If not he'll be a Kordell Stewart like player when his mobility declines.

[TheOracle]

I think you have to go Brees. He's only 32 so he should have at least 5 more years in him at a very high level. He's one of the most accurate passers the game has seen. Who knows if Cam will ever get to that level.

Brees is an old 32.

[savage]

Cam. Cam is more fun to watch play.

[saints4life25]

As a Saints fan I find this a very interesting topic and have enjoyed reading the responses.

I don't think there's really an easy answer. Especially only seeing Cam play for one year and exceed expectations the way he did. Who's to say hes going to continue that trend though.

While Drew is one of a few elite qbs in the league right now he is 32. He has been playing at an amazing level since arriving in New Orleans but at what point do you start to think about a decline?

I guess for 5 years I would say Brees. He gives you a legitimate shot at the Super Bowl for the next 3. Anything after that I would say Cam. In five years he should be hitting his prime.

It would be an interesting question after seeing if Cam can keep up this level of productivity though.

Good topic.

[the butch]

being a panther fan, i would say cam. being a neutral and detached observer, i would say give me brees for now, but ask the question in about 3 seasons. let cam prove he can do it again and again.