So Right now...Peyton or Eli?

[chef17]

Let's be real, if you were to put up Peyton against Eli in an eight year period, which is as long as Eli has been in the NFL, Eli is better. They were even discussing that tonight on NFLN. Peyton may be a bit better than Eli in stats during the season but as far as actual accomplishments, which means SB wins, Eli has the upper hand. And Eli has a better post season run than his brother.

Lets be real, SB wins are a team accomplishment. When you are comparing QB stats, Eli hasn't always been better and until recently it hasn't even been close.

2005 Peyton had better season and post season stats, both one and done.

2006 Peyton had better season and Colts won the Superbowl

2007 Peyton had better season but Giants won Superbowl

2008 Peyton had a better both, both one and done.

2009 Peyton had better season and Eli misses playoffs.

2010 same story.

You can argue Eli is better now, but to say Eli has always been better (which was your original claim) is 100% false and there is absolutely nothing that supports it

[Dpantherman]

This argument like most others around here comes down to how short term your memory is.

Seeing as I was only talking about the playoffs, there is nothing wrong with my memory. And I NEVER said that Peyton was better than Eli.

And I just want this thread to die now.

1) because my original post and the argument I wanted to get across do not match

2) I'm tired of talking about it. (my fault for bumping it)

[Dpantherman]

I should start taking my own advice