55 replies to this topic

[Floppin]

your entitled to your opinion.. but im not wrong.. well see.

Irrefutable logic this is.

[xclr82xtc]

Wow.

you think eli is more talented than cam?

[Ivan The Awesome]

i know im stating the obvious here, but for those that dont really know...(i see newcomers on this board) there is really something to be excited about here..

Cam Newton
Deangelo WIlliams
Steve Smith
Jonathan Stewart
Mark Tolbert
Ryan Kallil
Greg Olsen
John Beason
thomas davis
luke kuechly
Chris Gamble
Charles Johnson



i mean... really... LOL.. i challenge ANYONE to compile a list of 12 players ALL from one team that is as good as that list...

and im not gonna make another list but if you had to take whats left... man we have some REALLY talented players on this team..

after you sit back and really look at the names and the numbers, its actually quite impressive.. for the first time in a few seasons, i can say im fully behind the panthers front office..


for now.


ill wait..

Packers

Aaron Rodgers
Jordy Nelson
Greg Jennings
Jermichael Finley
Randall Cobb
James Starks
John Kuhn
Clay Matthews
B.J. Raji
Charles Woodson
A.J. Hawk
Nick Perry (Since you named a Rookie)

Pats

Tom Brady
Wes Welker
Nate Solder
Rob Gronkowski
Aaron Hernanderz
Brandon Lloyd
Julian Edlemen
Stevan ridley
Danny Woodhead
Devin McCourty
Vince Willfork
Chandler Jones


Just what I can remember of.


One thing is being confident another is being a bit arrogant. Our team is good, but not that good.

[xclr82xtc]

ill give you the packers.. (although i disagree with a couple names) but not the patriots. there is some big names on the list, but over all package, Ours is better.


either way, it proves a point that we have one of the best rosters in the NFL. look at the three teams we have compared to so far.. the champs, the packers, and the patriots.. arguably the top 3 teams in the NFL right now.


and add to the fact that we have the youngest team in the NFL.. (average 25 years of age) if the panthers stay healthy, the sky is the limit..

[Irv]

i thought about it but hen i went to go take a poop

[MasterAwesome]

I know I'm nitpicking here...but I don't get the love for John Kuhn (not just from the post in here, but the fact that he was voted in the Top 100 players of 2012). He's the fullback for a team that doesn't run (or at least doesn't run successfully)...so if he is getting so much praise, you'd think he is tearing it up on the ground or in the passing game, but he had less than 100 yards in both areas last season. He had a pretty good amount of TDs for a fullback, but that just means mostly that GB was in a lot of goal-line situations. If John Kuhn is getting praise in those regards...then Mike Tolbert should be considered the best player of all time. Is he just an insanely gifted pass blocker or something?

[TruCatzFan]

Can we get another pinned "Huddle Declaration" thread. One that fully discusses that silly threads like this one will be Locked immediately from here on out.... I'm getting tired of reading threads where the OP doesn't even know our own players by name.

[KillerKat]

Joe Flacco
Torrey Smith
Anquan Boldin
Ray Rice
Ray Lewis
Terrell Suggs
Ed Reed
Terrence Cody
Vonta Leach
Haloti Ngata
Jameel McClain
Lardarius Webb
Jacoby Jones
Michael Oher
Matt Birk

That's 15 from 1 other team. They also got their rookie Courtney Upshaw.

[xclr82xtc]

Can we get another pinned "Huddle Declaration" thread. One that fully discusses that silly threads like this one will be Locked immediately from here on out.... I'm getting tired of reading threads where the OP doesn't even know our own players by name.

...i just named 12 of them.. would you like me to name 12 more?

...how bout we lock all stupid comments...

[KillerKat]

...i just named 12 of them.. would you like me to name 12 more?

...how bout we lock all stupid comments...

Then this thread would still be locked

[cbarrier90]

...how bout we lock all stupid comments...

Edit: Dangit, KK beat me to it! ^

[thatlookseasy]

...i just named 12 of them.. would you like me to name 12 more?

...how bout we lock all stupid comments...

I dont think you would enjoy that

Edit: lol I'm too slow

[L-TownCat]

If and only if we stuck solely with the offense I could see a valid arguement.

Cam
Smitty
Jstew
Dwill
Tolbert
Lafell
Gettis
Olsen
Gross
Kallil

That is just as talented as any team in the league player to player. The arguement comes when you look at the group as a whole and the system it employs. With chud running the show and all those weapons at his disposal I'm really wondering what in the world 13 d-coordinators are gonna come up with to stop it. Quite honestly in the 20 years of really watching football I've never seen a total package quite like this.

Just think cam under center, Tolbert lined up behind him with both Stewart and Williams flanking him. Smitty and lafell/gettis/Adams on the outside. Move smitty across the formation and snap the ball. What do you do?

[chef17]

...i just named 12 of them.. would you like me to name 12 more?

...how bout we lock all stupid comments...

You named 12 what? Certainly not players because Mark Tolbert, Ryan Kallil, and John Beason aren't the name of any players

[Jackofalltrades]

you think eli is more talented than cam?

My remark, as short as it was, was directed at the elementary use of the English language. A place where children have not yet mastered the difference between your and you're. Things of that nature.

However, I'm as optimistic as anyone when it comes to the team and particularly the offense but to annoint them the most talented roster in the NFL is a bit of a stretch. Is Eli more talented? No, but he's more accomplished. I do think Rodgers is as talented and then you list the stars in that team it's not hard to see why they've been so good the last several years. There are probably ten teams that could boast a dozen very good players.

This is completely subjective and arguing over who has the best roster is fruitless, but it's hard to dismiss the defending Champs.