Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Cary Kollins

Your Top 10 Panthers of all-time

41 posts in this topic

Steve Smith

Cam Newton

Jake Delhomme

Stephen Davis

Julius Peppers

Jon Beason

Muhsin Muhammad

Dan Morgan

DeAngelo Williams

Jonathan Stewart

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Steve Smith: Unquestionable. Best player and best play in Panthers history

2) Jake Delhomme: Great leader & clutch in so many games before he lost it. Had the Panthers in position to pull off what would have been one of the greatest SB upsets of all-time

3) Julius Peppers: Best athlete in the Panthers history. Hate the way he left, but odds-on favorite to be the 1st player in the HoF who spent most of his career here.

4) Mushin Muhammed: Underrated everywhere except here. One of the better receivers of the decade from 1998-2008. Will always wonder what-if he had never had his 3 year hiatus in Chicago and him and Smitty could have torn it up together for longer. His 85 yard TD in the Super Bowl still gives me chills to watch.

5) Jordan Gross: One of the better offensive lineman over the past decade, has been a mainstay for the Panthers at both LT and RT. Great leader, really hope him and Smitty get another shot at the SB before they're done.

6) Chris Gamble: Also sometimes easy to overlook, but he has been solid for almost all of his career. It's a shame he's never been to a Pro Bowl despite some really worthy campaigns.

7) Sam Mills: So much has already been said but a great leader and player on some of the earlier teams. Would be higher on my list had he played longer here.

8) Jon Beason: Also a great leader and one of the best LB's in the league before his injury. Hoping he will be able to move higher in years to come.

9) Wesley Walls: Would have been more widely known nationally had he played in the fantasy football era. His TD celebration is still one of my all-time favorites.

10) Deangelo Williams: His highlight reel matches up well with any RB over the past 5 years. Will never get the recoginition due him b/c of splitting carries, but a career average of over 5 yd/carry and has made some of the best highlight plays in Panther history outside of Smitty

Honerable mention: John Kasey, Kris Jenkins, Jonathon Stewart, Eric Davis, Mike Minter, Mike Rucker, Dan Morgan, Stephen Davis

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm putting a 5 season minimum on my list.(disqualifies people like Cam, Kevin Greene,etc. that otherwise would have made it)

Smith

Gamble

Deangelo

Jenkins

Peppers

Eric Davis

Gross

Beason

Moose

Walls

Just missing the cut with the pre-qualifier I added would be

Minter

Rucker

Delhomme

Kasay

Dan Morgan

Kalil

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jake

TD

Walls

Goins

Morgan

Sam Mills

greene

Smitty

Moose

#10 is a tie since I loved them for a short time.......but I loved them alot!

Manning Jr/D.Foster

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dan Morgan

Jon Beason

Mike Minter

Julius Peppers

Chris Gamble

Jake Delhomme

Steve Smith

Wesley Walls

Stephen Davis

Brad Hoover

Double Trouble

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Biakabutuka (why I'm a Panther's fan in the first place, will forever be at the top of my list)

Then the rest in no real particular order

Smitty

Stew

Cam (maybe he shouldn't be up here yet, but I couldn't resist)

Kasay

Hoover

Moose

Delhomme

Minter

Beason

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Steve Smith

2. Wesley Walls

3. John Kasay

4. Julius Peppers

5. D Will

6. Jordan Gross

7. Dan Morgan

8. Jake Delhomme

9. Steve Beuerlein

10. Mike Minter/Brad Hoover

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kerry Collins

Wesley Walls

Sam Mills

Kevin Greene

Fred Lane

Smitty

J Stew

Beason

Gamble

Cam Newton

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cam Newton

CAm Newton

CaM Newton

Cam newton

Cam NEwton

Cam NeWton

Cam NewTon

Cam NewtOn

Cam NewtoN

Can Nooton

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Top 10

1. Steve Smith

2. Muhsin Muhammad

3. Jake Delhomme

4. Sam Mills

5. Mike Minter

6. Cam Newton

7. Jon Beason

8. John Kasay

9. Mark Fields

10. DeAngelo Williams

Others

Brad Hoover

Wesley Walls

Jordan Gross

Ryan Kalil

Jonathan Stewart

DeShaun Foster

Stephen Davis

Chris Gamble

Julius Peppers

Mike Rucker

Dan Morgan

Will Weatherspoon

Ricky Proehl

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I liked a couple of lists so no need to repost. Here's a few that I would add to "old guys"

Honorable Mention

Tyrone Poole - just for schooling Jerry Rice and punching out that reception in candlestick

Fred Lane - adding some personality

Rod Smart, "He Hate Me" - see above x's 10

Garcia - would fight at a drop of the hat.

Nick Goings - tough, competitive, under-rated..... mr panther in so many matchups

Karl Hankton - would wake up the sidelines (both sides) with his special teams hits.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Smith

Newton

Mills

Rucker

Beason

Minter

Greene

Jenkins

Moose

Morgan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites