Jump to content

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Carolina Husker

Question for Conservatives:

Recommended Posts

Matt Foley    1

i'm not sure how what rummy, bush and cheney "may" have said to each other has any baring on how torture should be handled by this country. if you're going to speculate, at least stay on topic.

Aren't they the ones that set the "new" policy?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cookinwithgas    7,383

They "should" have said, "Hey, it's illegal! We could get in trouble for this, but gosh darn it, we believe it's such a great idea we are willing to go to jail for doing it!"

Not, "Hey! Lets send them to Eastern Europe or Cuba and do it, it's like we never actually did it then, right? We're scot free!"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Matt Foley    1

They "should" have said, "Hey, it's illegal! We could get in trouble for this, but gosh darn it, we believe it's such a great idea we are willing to go to jail for doing it!"

Not, "Hey! Lets send them to Eastern Europe or Cuba and do it, it's like we never actually did it then, right? We're scot free!"

I think they said "We're not dealing with the Russians or the Germans or the Japanese here. We're dealing with people hell bent on killing as many innocent people as possible to make a statement for their cause. We better change our approach or else."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mmmbeans    443

Aren't they the ones that set the "new" policy?

I'm going to assume that since this is what you latched onto that you agreed with everything else I said.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mmmbeans    443

I think they said "We're not dealing with the Russians or the Germans or the Japanese here. We're dealing with people hell bent on killing as many innocent people as possible to make a statement for their cause. We better change our approach or else."

9/11x1,000,000?

/this whole statement is blindingly retarded. You wanna kill innocent people? You talk to the germans and the russians.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Matt Foley    1

9/11x1,000,000?

/this whole statement is blindingly retarded. You wanna kill innocent people? You talk to the germans and the russians.

Point was, the Russians, Germans, Japanese, and every other enemy we ever had went after military targets. They didn't plant cells in our country and plan 9/11 attacks. I mean, the Japanese used surprise but at least they attacked a navy base.

And yes, I wanna kill innocent people. You know any?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mmmbeans    443

Point was, the Russians, Germans, Japanese, and every other enemy we ever had went after military targets. They didn't plant cells in our country and plan 9/11 attacks. I mean, the Japanese used surprise but at least they attacked a navy base.

And yes, I wanna kill innocent people. You know any?

so? I keep hearing this argument... Are you suggesting that if they'd blown up a military base instead of the towers that you'd be on here right now decrying the horrors of torture? What about the Marines in lebanon? They were fair game?

I'm not the one putting rules on war, you are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Matt Foley    1

so? I keep hearing this argument... Are you suggesting that if they'd blown up a military base instead of the towers that you'd be on here right now decrying the horrors of torture? What about the Marines in lebanon? They were fair game?

I'm not the one putting rules on war, you are.

I'm saying the rules of war were redefined by the terrorists.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cookinwithgas    7,383

Point was, the Russians, Germans, Japanese, and every other enemy we ever had went after military targets. They didn't plant cells in our country and plan 9/11 attacks. I mean, the Japanese used surprise but at least they attacked a navy base.

And yes, I wanna kill innocent people. You know any?

Meat is so smart. He interviewed people in Guernica, London, western Russia, Eastern Germany, the Lusitania, Nanking, Korea, and the Phillippines among other locations for this exclusive Fox News report.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Matt Foley    1

Meat is so smart. He interviewed people in Guernica, London, western Russia, Eastern Germany, the Lusitania, Nanking, Korea, and the Phillippines among other locations for this exclusive Fox News report.

:rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×